From -6.8% to 12.2%: 43 health systems ranked by operating margins

Health system operating margins improved in 2023 after a tumultuous 2022. Increased revenue from rebounding patient volumes helped offset the high costs of labor and supplies for many systems, but some continue to face challenges turning a financial corner. 

In a Feb. 21 analysis, Kaufman Hall noted that too many hospitals are losing money but high-performing hospitals are faring far better, "effectively pulling away from the pack." 

Average operating margins have see-sawed over the last 12 months, from a -1.2% low in February 2023 to 5.5% highs in June and December. In February, average operating margins dropped to 3.96% before the Change Healthcare data breach, which has impacted claims processing.

Here are 43 health systems ranked by operating margins in their most recent financial results.

Editor's note: The following financial results are for the 12 months ending Dec. 31, 2023, unless otherwise stated. 

1. Tenet Healthcare (Dallas)

Revenue: $20.55 billion
Expenses: $18.31 billion
Operating income/loss: $2.5 billion 
(*Includes grant income and equity in earnings of unconsolidated affiliates)
Operating margin: 12.2%

2. HCA Healthcare (Nashville, Tenn.)

Revenue: $65 billion
Expenses: $57.3 billion
Operating income/loss: $7.7 billion
Operating margin: 11.8%

3. Universal Health Services (King of Prussia, Pa.)

Revenue: $14.3 billion
Expenses: $13.1 billion
Operating income/loss: $1.2 billion
Operating margin: 8.4% 

4. Baylor Scott & White (Dallas)

*Results for the first six months ending Dec. 31
Revenue: $7.6 billion
Expenses: $7 billion
Operating income/loss: $634 million
Operating margin: 8.3%

5. NYU Langone (New York City)

*Results for the 12 months ending Aug. 31
Revenue: $8.3 billion
Expenses: $7.7 billion
Operating income/loss: $686.2 million
Operating margin: 8.3%

6. Orlando (Fla.) Health

*Results for the 12 months ending Sept. 30
Revenue: $6.1 billion
Expenses: $5.6 billion
Operating income/loss: $491.3 million
Operating margin: 8.1%

7. Community Health Systems (Franklin, Tenn.)

Revenue: $12.5 billion
Expenses: $11.5 billion
Operating income/loss: $957 million
Operating margin: 7.7% 

8. Mayo Clinic (Rochester, Minn)

Revenue: $17.9 billion
Expenses: $16.8 billion
Operating income/loss: $1.1 billion 
Operating margin: 6%

9. Sanford Health (Sioux Falls, S.D.)

Revenue: $7.2 billion
Expenses: $6.8 billion
Operating income/loss: $402.2 million
Operating margin: 5.6%

10. Stanford Health Care (Palo Alto, Calif.)

*Results for the 12 months ending Aug. 31
Revenue: $7.9 billion
Expenses: $7.5 billion
Operating income/loss: $414.9 million
Operating margin: 5.3%

11. Christus Health (Irving, Texas)

*For the 12 months ending June 30 
Revenue: $7.8 billion
Expenses: $7.5 billion
Operating income/loss: $324.5 million
Operating margin: 4.2%

12. IU Health (Indianapolis)

Revenue: $8.6 billion
Expenses: $8.3 billion
Operating income/loss: $343 million
Operating margin: 4%

13. Northwestern Medicine (Chicago)

*Results for the 12 months ending Sept. 30
Revenue: $8.7 billion
Expenses: $8.4 billion
Operating income/loss: $352.3 million
Operating margin: 4%

14. BJC HealthCare (St. Louis)

Revenue: $6.9 billion
Expenses: $6.8 billion
Operating income/loss: $141.6 million
Operating margin: 2%

15. Banner Health (Phoenix)

Revenue: $14.1 billion
Expenses: $13.8 billion
Operating income/loss: $282.8 million
Operating margin: 2%

16. Sharp HealthCare (San Diego) 

*Results for the 12 months ending Sept. 30
Revenue: $4.74 billion
Expenses: $4.65 billion
Operating income/loss: $88.3 million
Operating margin: 1.9%

17. Norton Healthcare (Louisville, Ky.)

Revenue: $4 billion
Expenses: $3.8 billion
Operating income/loss: $76.3 million
Operating margin: 1.9%

18. Montefiore Health (New York City)

Revenue: $7.7 billion
Expenses: $7.6 billion
Operating income/loss: $93.9 million
Operating margin: 1.2%

19. Penn State Health (Hershey, Pa.)

*Results for the first six months ending Dec. 31
Revenue: $2.1 billion
Expenses: $2 billion
Operating income/loss: $22.9 million
Operating margin: 1.1%

20. Prisma Health (Greenville, S.C.)

*For the 12 months ending Sept. 30
Revenue: $6 billion
Expenses: $5.9 billion
Operating income/loss: $67.1 million
Operating margin: 1.1%

21. HonorHealth (Scottsdale, Ariz.)

Revenue: $3.1 billion
Expenses: $3 billion
Operating income/loss: $32.8 million
Operating margin: 1.1%

22. Henry Ford Health (Detroit)

Revenue: $7.8 billion
Expenses: $7.7 billion
Operating income/loss: $80.5 million
Operating margin: 1%

23. Intermountain Health (Salt Lake City)

Revenue: $16.1 billion
Expenses: $15.2 billion
Operating income/loss: $137 million
Operating margin: 0.9%

24. Advocate Health (Charlotte, N.C.)

*For the nine months ending Sept. 30
Revenue: $22.83 billion
Expenses: $22.75 billion
Operating income/loss: $79.4 million
Operating margin: 0.4%

25. Cleveland Clinic

Revenue: $14.5 billion
Expenses: $13.7 billion
Operating income/loss: $64.3 million
Operating margin: 0.4%

26. OSF HealthCare (Peoria, Ill.)

*For the 12 months ending Sept. 30
Revenue: $4.1 billion
Expenses: $4.1 billion
Operating income/loss: $1.2 million
Operating margin: 0%

27. CommonSpirit (Chicago) 

*Results for the first six months ending Dec. 31
Revenue: $18.69 billion
Expenses: $18.63 billion
Operating income/loss: ($46 million)
Operating margin: (0.2%)

28. Kaiser Permanente (Oakland, Calif.)

Revenue: $100.8 billion
Expenses: $100.5 billion
Operating income/loss: $329 million
Operating margin: (0.3% margin) 

29. Mass General Brigham (Boston)

*Results for the 12 months ended Sept. 30
Revenue: $18.8 billion
Expenses: $18.7 billion
Operating income/loss: ($48 million)
Operating margin: (0.3%)

30. Geisinger Health (Danville, Pa.)

Revenue: $7.7 billion
Expenses: $7.8 billion
Operating income/loss: ($37 million)
Operating margin: (0.5%)

31. SSM Health (St. Louis)

Revenue: $10.5 billion
Expenses: $10.6 billion
Operating income/loss: ($58.5 million)
Operating margin: (0.6%)

32. UPMC (Pittsburgh)

Revenue: $27.7 billion
Expenses: $27.9 billion
Operating income/loss: ($198 million)
Operating margin: (0.7%)

33. Scripps Health (San Diego)

*For the 12 months ending Sept. 30
Revenue: $4.3 billion
Expenses: $4.3 billion
Operating income/loss: ($36.6 million)
Operating margin: (0.9%)

34. Ascension (St. Louis)

*Results for the first six months ending Dec. 31
Revenue: $15.01 billion
Expenses: $15.03 billion
Operating income/loss: ($155.2 million)
Operating margin: (1%)

35. Bon Secours Mercy Health (Cincinnati)

Revenue: $12.2 billion
Expenses: $12.4 billion
Operating income/loss: ($123.9 million)
Operating margin: (1%)

36. ProMedica (Toledo, Ohio)

Revenue: $3.3 billion
Expenses: $3.1 billion
Operating income/loss: ($44.5 million)
Operating margin: (1.3%)

37. Beth Israel Lahey Health (Cambridge, Mass.)

*Results for the 12 months ending Sept. 30
Revenue: $7.7 billion
Expenses: $7.8 billion
Operating income/loss: ($131.2 million)
Operating margin: (1.7%)

38. Geisinger (Danville, Pa.)

*Results for the nine months ending Sept. 30,
Revenue: $5.7 billion
Expenses: $2.3 billion
Operating income/loss: ($104.4 million)
Operating margin: (1.8%)

39. Premier Health (Dayton, Ohio)

Revenue: $2.3 billion
Expenses: $2.4 billion
Operating income/loss: ($85.3 million)
Operating margin: (3.7%)

40. Allegheny Health Network (Pittsburgh)

Revenue: $4.7 billion
Expenses: $4.2 billion
Operating income/loss: ($172.7 million)
Operating margin: (3.7% margin) 

41. Providence (Renton, Wash.)

Revenue: $28.7 billion
Expenses: $29.9 billion
Operating income/loss: ($1.2 billion)
Operating margin: (4.2%)

42. Tufts Medicine (Boston)

*Results for the 12 months ending Sept. 30
Revenue: $2.6 billion
Expenses: $2.8 billion
Operating income/loss: ($171 million)
Operating margin: (6.6%)

43. Allina Health (Minneapolis)

Revenue: $5.2 billion
Expenses: $5.5 billion
Operating income/loss: ($352.6 million)
Operating margin: (6.8%)

Copyright © 2024 Becker's Healthcare. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy. Cookie Policy. Linking and Reprinting Policy.

 

Featured Whitepapers

Featured Webinars