Hospital ownership structures rarely make headlines until they’re under pressure. But two recent transactions — one driven by long-term strategic planning and another by financial strain — are highlighting a question more health system leaders are asking: When does it make sense to become a nonprofit?
Fort Myers, Fla.-based Lee Health converted from a public entity to a private nonprofit on Nov. 1, 2024, a proactive move by a financially stable system. Brentwood, Tenn.-based Quorum Health, a for-profit operator, has signed a definitive agreement to become a nonprofit in a deal expected to close this fall. One system moved from a position of strength. The other moved to ensure survival.
For health system leaders weighing their own structure, the two stories together answer a more useful question than either does alone: under what conditions does a nonprofit conversion actually make financial sense?
The case for survival
Chris Harrison, who previously served as CFO, told Becker’s the planned nonprofit conversion would better position the health system for long-term sustainability as rural hospitals face mounting financial and operational pressures.
“We’re geographically dispersed and spread out, so we don’t really get economies of scale in our markets and operating as a for-profit has made it challenging to partner with larger operators in our markets,” Mr. Harrison said.
Quorum operates 11 hospitals across nine states, a dispersed footprint that yields little economies of scale and makes it difficult to partner with larger operators while structured as a for-profit, according to Mr. Harrison. The nonprofit structure changes the math on capital.
“[This transaction gives] us an ability to operate under a much lower cost of debt and to emerge from the transaction with a much healthier balance sheet and credit rating,” he said.
Lower debt service frees up cash flow. The company plans to invest more than $300 million into capital projects through 2029, including outpatient facilities, freestanding emergency departments and tech upgrades. About 75% of its hospitals are sole community providers or critical access hospitals, the rural facilities most exposed when capital costs climb.
The path to this point was its own argument. Spun off from Franklin, Tenn.-based Community Health Systems in 2016, Quorum filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2020 to shed roughly $500 million in debt and has since shrunk from 21 hospitals to 11.
“You sometimes get stronger by getting smaller,” Mr. Harrison said. “We improved our balance sheet, paid off some debt, improved our margins and improved our focus so we could concentrate on those assets.”
The case from strength
By contrast, Lee Health reached the same structure on very different terms. Its conversion was not a rescue.
“Lee Health’s decision to convert from a public entity to a private nonprofit health system was a critical step toward ensuring a sustainable and vibrant future in an increasingly complex healthcare environment,” Lee Health President and CEO Larry Antonucci, MD, said.
The system projected a $1 billion gain in net patient revenue over 10 years from the move, framing private nonprofit status as a way to preserve local governance and gain strategic flexibility rather than to avert collapse.
One year in, the results read like a system investing, not retrenching: $168 million in charity care in 2025, a $150 million expansion at its Fort Myers campus that will add 92 inpatient beds, and a new 60-bed rehabilitation hospital opened with Encompass Health.
Lee Health has also grown substantially since the conversion.
“With the ability to establish clinics and practices beyond Lee County, we acquired Prime MD Naples,” Dr. Antonucci said. “In Cape Coral, southwest Florida’s fastest-growing community, we expanded access through the opening of Lee Health at Bimini Square, bringing together comprehensive adult and pediatric physician and outpatient services, Convenient Care in South Cape Coral, and an expanded emergency department. Additional growth is underway across the region to ensure patients receive high-quality, compassionate care closer to home.”
Moody’s also affirmed the system’s “A2” rating and revised its outlook to positive.
That last detail matters for any executive modeling a conversion. A ratings agency rewarding the move with a better outlook is the clearest external signal that the structure — not just the balance sheet — carries weight with lenders.
What it means for the balance sheet
The common thread is the cost of capital. For-profit and public structures both impose constraints that nonprofit status can loosen: for-profits carry higher debt costs and shareholder expectations, while public entities can be boxed in by government budgeting and limited access to tax-exempt financing. Nonprofit status opens the door to lower-cost, tax-exempt debt and the free cash flow that follows.
For health system leaders evaluating their own organization’s structures, the framework Mr. Harrison outlined is highly transferable. The questions are straightforward: What is your current cost of debt, and how much could tax-exempt financing reduce it? How much capital would lower debt service free up, and where could it be reinvested? Does your current structure support your scale and strategy, or is it becoming a constraint?
The two systems also mark the boundaries of the decision. Conversion can be a growth strategy, as it was for Lee Health, or a survival strategy, as it is for Quorum. It is not a universal fix. A system without a credible operating plan does not become viable by changing its tax status, and the regulatory review that governs these conversions — still pending for Quorum — can be lengthy and is not guaranteed.
What both cases confirm is that capital structure has moved from a back-office concern to a strategic lever. As reimbursement pressure and borrowing costs squeeze margins across the industry, more systems are likely to ask the question Lee Health and Quorum have already answered for themselves.
At the Becker's 11th Annual IT + Revenue Cycle Conference: The Future of AI & Digital Health, taking place September 14–17 in Chicago, healthcare executives and digital leaders from across the country will come together to explore how AI, interoperability, cybersecurity, and revenue cycle innovation are transforming care delivery, strengthening financial performance, and driving the next era of digital health. Apply for complimentary registration now.