Health systems planning for a physician shortage may already be behind. The Association of American Medical Colleges projects a shortage of up to 86,000 physicians by 2036.
During a Sept. 17 webinar hosted by Becker’s Healthcare and CHG Healthcare, Melinda Giese, senior vice president of enterprise client solutions, called the shortage a present-day problem, not one a decade away and laid out how organizations can build a workforce strategy around it.
Ms. Giese has spent the last nine years at CHG Healthcare helping hospitals adapt their workforce strategies. CHG Healthcare is a physician and advanced practice provider (including CRNAs, NPs and PAs) workforce solutions organization.
Previously, she had roles on the payer side and in technology enablement and payment integrity.
Here are five key takeaways from the session.
Editor’s note: Unless otherwise noted, statistics in this article come from research compiled CHG Healthcare, including proprietary CHG reserach and outside sources cited.
1. Treat retention as seriously as recruitment
Volume-based recruiting will not solve the physician shortage alone. CHG Healthcare’s physician sentiment research uncovered that physicians now rank autonomy above compensation and systems that see results tend to tailor that autonomy to the individual’s personal and professional priorities, career stage and specialty. Ms. Giese emphasized that now is the time for health systems to respond to shifting physician preferences.Satisfaction can also be a misleading metric. The reserach found 74% of physicians say they’re satisfied with their current role, but only 64% expect to stay 12 months or more with their current organization and fewer than one in three would recommend their healthcare organization to a colleague. “Physician satisfaction does not necessarily equal physician loyalty, creating hidden workforce risk,” Ms. Giese said.
Physician engagement pays back in measurable ways, with engaged physicians sending 51% more inpatient referrals than disengaged peers and a 3.2-point turnover rate gap between top- and bottom-quartile organizations. One structural fix she pointed to is giving physician well-being the same executive priority as quality and safety.
2. Account for the rising cost of open roles
Ms. Giese mentioned, around 72% of physicians are approached about other jobs at least monthly. Physician roles now take 148 days to fill on average, up nearly 16% since 2019. Specialty and surgical roles take about 176 days.
Across the 10 most affected specialties, CHG Healthcare estimates an open position represents about $9.4 million in lost gross billables on average, based on a median of 167 days to fill.
Mean total compensation rose 11.4% for surgical specialists and 10.8% for primary care physicians from 2021 to 2024, Ms. Giese said citing Medical Group Management Association data, while cumulative inflation over the same period was about 20%.
According to CHG Healthcare, organizations now pay an average of $37,000 in retention bonuses. With only 39% of health systems reporting a formal physician retention strategy and 16% reporting none. Ms. Giese reinforced that healthcare organizations should develop a long-term physician workforce plan, prioritizing the most impactful changes within leadership control regarding current physician preferences.
3. Build flexibility into the workforce
Better work-life balance is the leading reason physicians change jobs across all career stages, Flexible schedules are also a top priority, particularly among late-career physicians. “If your only engagement model is full-time W-2 employment, you’re not speaking the language this workforce demands,” Ms. Giese said.
According to CHG Healthcare research, 26% of physicians are very or extremely interested in locum tenens work, up from 11% in 2017. The research also reports 57% of physicians say they’re likely to work in a float pool. Ms. Giese described a tiered approach that turns first to permanent providers and internal float pools, then to telehealth, advanced practice providers and locum tenens.
As physician float pools mature, organizations are partnering with CHG Healthcare to build several physician float pool models. This includes hub-and-spoke arrangements, regional specialty teams, virtual float pools, internal staffing marketplaces and enterprise-wide coverage teams. While structures vary, CHG Healthcare designs each model to create greater agility when demand shifts unexpectedly.
4. Build APPs and locum tenens into the care model
Advanced practice providers, such as nurse practitioners and physician assistants, make up about 40% of providers in physician practices and 92% of organizations call them very or extremely important to workforce strategy. Ms. Giese outlined three common APP deployment models, built around access, population health and new business goals. In each, the organization standardizes how APPs are used at the group, specialty or practice level rather than leaving it to individual physician-APP pairs.
Locum tenens physicians work best when matched to a specific business goal, Ms. Giese said. These goals could be maintaining access and referrals in specialties, relieving burnout in high-volume services like oncology or anesthesiology, or driving procedural revenue in specialties such as gastroenterology, radiology and urology.
Ms. Giese highlighted that in those procedural specialties, a locum physician can generate $2.7 million to $3.7 million or more annually, if billing and payer enrollment are handled correctly. She expressed the right physician staffing partner should not simply fill gaps, but help health systems execute a sustainable workforce strategy that strengthens access, retention, and organizational performance.
5. Use purpose-built workforce technology
Ms. Giese described technology as a strategic enabler that can bring scheduling, credentialing, vendor coordination, billing visibility, and forecasting together in one place. Health systems using a specific physician and APP locum vendor management system (VMS) can gain real-time visibility into spend, utilization and billing accuracy across facilities, specialties and contracts.
AI tools can shorten time to fill by speeding candidate matching and screening. CHG Healthcare is using AI to improve the speed and quality of physician and APP matches while recruiters still play an important role.
For physicians, Ms. Giese predicts AI is more likely to relieve administrative burden than to replace anyone. But according to CHG Healthcare research, 71% of physicians want input on technology decisions and only 30% say they have it.
“The concern isn’t the technology itself, it’s that deployment decisions are being made without physician input. Part of the solution is to involve physicians in technology and AI decisions to remove skepticism and barriers to adoption,” Ms. Giese said.
Closing the physician gap
The combination of tight physician supply, inconsistent deployment, and rising demand has reshaped workforce challenges across healthcare.
Through its work with health systems nationwide, CHG Healthcare has seen organizations make the most progress when they move beyond one-off staffing fixes and build physician and APP workforces designed to perform under pressure, strengthening core physician capacity, expanding flexible coverage models, and using technology to reduce friction across recruitment, credentialing, deployment and scheduling.
“There is no single solution, but a series of connected solutions truly can help formulate a plan to close the physician gap,” Ms. Giese said.