Is medicine pushing older physicians out?

Advertisement

Health systems are caught between two workforce realities that pull in opposite directions. Their physician workforce is aging faster than new physicians are graduating, and the tools many hospitals use to keep older physicians practicing safely may be hastening their exit.

The share of physicians 65 or older doubled from about 11% in 2005 to 22.4% in 2025, according to Association of American Medical Colleges data. Nearly 47% of active physicians are 55 or older, up from 38% in 2007.

To manage that shift, an estimated 200 hospitals and health systems now run late-career practitioner programs that require physicians 70 and older to undergo cognitive and physical screening before their privileges are renewed, typically every one or two years. In a tally of 29 such programs, about 80% required reassessment every two years, nearly 90% required a physical exam and about 83% required a neuropsychological exam, the American Council on Science and Health reported Nov. 18, citing a 2026 JAMA Health Forum analysis.

The programs are surfacing real risk. Studies at Yale New Haven (Conn.) Hospital and Hartford HealthCare found that 12.7% to 14.4% of screened physicians over 70 showed some degree of cognitive impairment. Mild cognitive impairment rises from 8.4% of adults ages 65 to 69 to 25.3% of those ages 80 to 84, according to the American Academy of Neurology.

But the programs are also moving physicians out of practice before any impairment is identified. More than 25% of physicians targeted for re-examination resigned before screening, according to an Annals of Internal Medicine study cited by ACSH, with many describing the process as intrusive, stigmatizing or potentially unfair. Others are choosing retirement over the evaluations altogether.

Thomas Gallagher, MD, a bioethicist at the University of Washington in Seattle, has described how some physicians react to being screened.

“This [screening] really makes some doctors furious,” Dr. Gallagher told The Washington Post.

Every early exit carries a supply cost. The American Medical Association has estimated that a two-year drop in the average physician retirement age would reduce the 2036 physician supply by about 40,000, and HRSA projects a shortage of 141,160 full-time-equivalent physicians across 35 specialties by 2038. The pipeline behind late-career physicians is thinning too: Mid-career surgeons are more likely to leave clinical practice than their more- or less-experienced peers.

Whether health systems can use age as the trigger at all is now before a federal court. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission sued Yale New Haven Hospital in 2020, alleging that its 2016 late-career practitioner policy, which requires physicians 70 and older to undergo eye and neuropsychological exams, amounts to age discrimination. Yale New Haven has relied on a provision of the Americans with Disabilities Act that allows medical examinations in certain cases, and a hospital spokesperson has said the policy, which remains in force, is “designed to find a small subset of older physicians who represent a patient safety risk.” On Oct. 23, the court denied both sides’ motions for a ruling without trial, sending the case to trial. Even so, the court gave weight to the premise behind the policy.

“There is no genuine dispute among the experts that the single greatest indicator of cognitive decline is age,” U.S. District Judge Kari Dooley wrote, according to ACSH.

Critics of age-based screening argue that a birthday is the wrong trigger. Average cognitive ability declines by more than 20% between ages 40 and 75, according to a JAMA Surgery article cited by ACSH, but the variation between individuals is wide. James Ellison, MD, co-director of the Comprehensive Alzheimer’s Center at Philadelphia-based Jefferson Health, made that case in a 2026 American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry article.

“Cognitive aging is heterogeneous [and] many clinicians retain or deepen clinically relevant capacities while others develop cognitive, medical, or sensory impairments that raise justifiable safety concerns,” Dr. Ellison wrote.

Several medical groups have backed an alternative: assessing competence across a physician’s entire career. The AMA advises evaluating physician competence throughout physicians’ careers and holds that age alone should not prompt an assessment, according to ACSH. The American College of Surgeons has endorsed a whole-of-career assessment for surgeons of all ages that combines clinical outcomes, health assessments and standardized cognitive measures, escalating to chart reviews, procedure observation and peer feedback if concerns arise. Dr. Ellison and his colleagues have proposed quality assurance testing across a practitioner’s entire career, tailored to the skills each field requires. Psychiatrists, for example, do not need the eyesight required of surgeons, ACSH noted.

For now, much of the field is waiting on New Haven. The EEOC lawsuit has chilled similar programs at some hospitals, while others are holding off until the federal court rules, Becker’s reported in February. Most medical associations recommend that screenings be voluntary.

Advertisement

Next Up in Physician Workforce

Advertisement