The Leapfrog Group has given 11 hospitals their 30th consecutive “A” safety grade and three hospitals an “F” in its fall 2026 Hospital Safety Grade update, released Nov. 18.
Leapfrog, a national patient safety nonprofit, grades general acute care hospitals twice a year, in the spring and fall, on how well they protect patients from preventable errors, injuries, accidents and infections. Each hospital receives a numerical score that Leapfrog converts to a letter grade from A to F. Scores draw on up to 22 measures from CMS, results from the voluntary Leapfrog Hospital Survey and supplemental data. Read more about Leapfrog’s fall 2026 methodology here.
Of the 729 hospitals that earned an “A” when Leapfrog issued its first grades in June 2012, 11 have held the top grade in every cycle since. The number of “F” hospitals fell to three from five in spring.
This fall’s grades are the first since Leapfrog said it would resume full grading after a court ruling limited its spring cycle. Five hospitals that are part of Palm Beach (Fla.) Health Network, a division of Dallas-based Tenet Healthcare, sued Leapfrog in April 2025 after three of the hospitals received an “F” safety grade and two earned a “D.”
The lawsuit alleged that, in a 2024 change to methodology, Leapfrog penalized hospitals that did not participate in its national surveys, claiming the low scores unfairly damaged the hospitals’ reputations. In March, a federal judge in Florida sided with the hospitals.
In September, Leapfrog appealed that judge’s decision; the organization says the safety grades are a constitutionally protected opinion. The lawsuit is now before the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Here are the locations of Leapfrog’s 11 straight-“A” and three “F” hospitals:
Leapfrog’s 11 straight-‘A’ hospitals:
- Endeavor Health Elmhurst (Ill.) Hospital
- French Hospital Medical Center (San Luis Obispo, Calif.)
- Inova Loudoun Hospital (Leesburg, Va.)
- Kaiser Permanente Orange County-Anaheim (Calif.) Medical Center
- Mayo Clinic (Phoenix)
- Northwestern Medicine Central DuPage Hospital (Winfield, Ill.)
- Sentara CarePlex Hospital (Hampton, Va.)
- Sentara Leigh Hospital (Norfolk, Va.)
- St. Anne’s Hospital (Fall River, Mass.)
- University of Chicago Medical Center
- Virginia Mason Medical Center (Seattle)
Leapfrog’s three ‘F’ hospitals:
- Howard University Hospital (Washington, D.C.)
- Roseland Community Hospital (Chicago)
- WVU Fairmont Medical Center (Fairmont, W.Va.)