How physician, nurse communication compare at 61 top-rated hospitals: CMS

Advertisement

CMS gave 61 hospitals five-star ratings in overall hospital quality in 2026. Of those, 58 also earned five-star ratings for nurse communication and 23 earned five-star ratings for physician communication. 

Becker’s compared nurse and physician communication star ratings from CMS’ Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems survey released Aug. 13, which captures patients’ experiences during a recent hospital stay, with the agency’s Overall Hospital Quality Star Rating, which factors in mortality, safety of care, readmissions, patient experience, and timely and effective care.

Of the top-rated hospitals, 95% also earned five stars for nurse communication, compared with 38% for physician communication. 

The Veterans Health Administration had the most hospitals on the lists: 16 of the 58 hospitals with five-star nurse communication ratings and 11 of the 23 with five stars across all three measures. Six specialty heart and orthopedic hospitals earned five stars for quality and nurse communication, but none earned five stars for physician communication. 

Only 23 hospitals across 20 states earned five stars across all measures, with physician communication being the limiting factor.

Here are the highest-rated quality and patient experience hospitals that also ranked five stars in nurse communication or physician communication.

Five-star quality and nurse communication

Arizona 

Mayo Clinic Hospital (Phoenix)

Arkansas 

Fayetteville VA Medical Center

California 

Scripps Green Hospital (La Jolla)

Colorado 

Grand Junction VA Medical Center

Florida 

Orlando VA Medical Center

Georgia 

AdventHealth Murray (Chatsworth) 

Memorial Health Meadows Hospital (Vidalia) 

Northeast Georgia Medical Center Lumpkin (Dahlonega) 

Southeastern Regional Medical Center (Newnan)

Idaho 

Boise VA Medical Center

Indiana 

Hendricks Regional Health (Danville) 

St. Vincent Heart Center (Carmel)

Iowa 

Van Diest Medical Center (Webster City) 

Waverly Health Center

Kansas 

Wichita VA Medical Center

Massachusetts 

Fairview Hospital (Great Barrington)

Michigan 

Corewell Health Zeeland Hospital 

VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System

Minnesota 

Mayo Clinic Hospital Rochester

Missouri 

Barnes-Jewish West County Hospital (Creve Coeur)

Montana 

VA Montana Healthcare System (Fort Harrison)

Nevada 

Carson Valley Health (Gardnerville)

North Carolina 

Novant Health Medical Park Hospital (Winston-Salem)

North Dakota 

Fargo VA Medical Center

Ohio 

Crystal Clinic Orthopaedic Center (Akron) 

Kettering Health Troy 

Memorial Hospital (Marysville) 

Mercy Allen Hospital (Oberlin)

Oklahoma 

Bailey Medical Center (Owasso) 

Chickasaw Nation Medical Center (Ada) 

Oklahoma Heart Hospital South (Oklahoma City)

Oregon 

Peace Harbor Medical Center (Florence)

Pennsylvania 

AHN Wexford Hospital 

Geisinger St. Luke’s Hospital (Orwigsburg) 

Lebanon VA Medical Center 

St. Luke’s Hospital-Carbon Campus (Lehighton) 

Wilkes-Barre VA Medical Center

South Carolina 

Mount Pleasant Hospital 

Pelham Medical Center (Greer)

South Dakota 

Avera Heart Hospital of South Dakota (Sioux Falls) 

Sioux Falls VA Medical Center

Tennessee 

Mountain Home VA Medical Center

Texas 

Baylor Scott & White The Heart Hospital-Dallas 

Baylor Scott & White The Heart Hospital-Denton 

Houston Methodist Clear Lake Hospital (Nassau Bay)

Utah 

Park City Hospital

Vermont 

White River Junction VA Medical Center

Virginia 

Page Memorial Hospital (Luray)

West Virginia 

Beckley VA Medical Center 

Hampshire Memorial Hospital (Romney) 

Huntington VA Medical Center 

Valley Health War Memorial Hospital (Berkeley Springs)

Wisconsin 

Madison VA Medical Center 

Mayo Clinic Health System-Franciscan Medical Center (La Crosse) 

River Falls Area Hospital 

Sauk Prairie Hospital (Prairie du Sac) 

Tomah Memorial Hospital

Wyoming 

St. John’s Medical Center (Jackson)

Five-star quality and physician communication

Arizona 

Mayo Clinic Hospital (Phoenix)

Arkansas 

Fayetteville VA Medical Center

California 

Scripps Green Hospital (La Jolla)

Colorado 

Grand Junction VA Medical Center

Florida 

Orlando VA Medical Center

Georgia 

AdventHealth Murray (Chatsworth)

Idaho 

Boise VA Medical Center

Iowa 

Van Diest Medical Center (Webster City)

Massachusetts 

Fairview Hospital (Great Barrington)

Michigan 

VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System

Montana 

VA Montana Healthcare System (Fort Harrison)

North Dakota 

Fargo VA Medical Center

Oregon 

Peace Harbor Medical Center (Florence)

Pennsylvania 

Lebanon VA Medical Center

Tennessee 

Mountain Home VA Medical Center

Utah 

Park City Hospital

Vermont 

White River Junction VA Medical Center

Virginia 

Page Memorial Hospital (Luray)

West Virginia 

Beckley VA Medical Center 

Hampshire Memorial Hospital (Romney) 

Valley Health War Memorial Hospital (Berkeley Springs)

Wisconsin 

River Falls Area Hospital 

Sauk Prairie Hospital (Prairie du Sac)

Advertisement

Next Up in Rankings and Ratings

Advertisement