At one point in his career, Scott Rathgaber, MD, was content being a gastroenterologist.
That changed after one of his employers went bankrupt, prompting him to pay much more attention to how the organization at his next career stop was run. In doing so, he made two discoveries: His own latent leadership abilities and how those abilities could guide not only his own career, but the careers of those he would lead.
“Two things drove my journey in leadership,” said Dr. Rathgaber, CEO of Emplify Health, which operates dual headquarters in Green Bay and La Crosse, Wis. “One was that I’d already learned a lot about gastroenterology, and I would go to meetings for maybe a week at a time and learn three new things. Whereas if I went to leadership events or read about leadership, I was learning giant amounts. So it was very exciting; it stimulated my brain. And then I finally came to the realization that while I could affect one life at a time and do pretty well — and that’s a great career — if I did leadership well, I could affect way more lives over my career.”
Dr. Rathgaber has served in the CEO role since the health system formed in December 2022 from the merger of La Crosse-based Gundersen Health and Green Bay-based Bellin Health. He had served as Gundersen Health’s CEO since 2015.
On the “Becker’s Healthcare Podcast,” he shared why he believes a “pit crew” leadership model beats the “cowboy mentality,” what’s on his reading list and how 15 minutes in a dark room can help him power through difficult days.
Editor’s note: Responses have been lightly edited for clarity and length.
Question: What is something that you’ve learned outside of healthcare that you’ve been able to apply to your career?
Dr. Scott Rathgaber: In my era of being trained in medicine, it was kind of “know all you can know, be an encyclopedia.” People describe it as the cowboy mentality, and we’ve really moved more to a pit crew way to provide care. It requires a team, but I had to learn that a little bit. And outside of healthcare, I really became a student of servant leadership. I learned that before you can lead, you really need to serve first. You don’t just step into leadership. You have to have the right mindset to learn how to serve others, because at the end of the day, leadership is serving everybody. And so the concept I brought from that investigation was this: Most people think of a pyramid. You’re going up to the point to be at the top when you’re the leader, right? Well, in servant leadership, it’s really an inverted pyramid. The more responsibility you take, you head toward the point, but it’s down, and you just have more people to serve. The patients, of course, are at that inverted base. But even all of your staff and everybody on the teams — you’re there to serve them, not the other way around. That mindset change made a big difference in how I approach leadership in my life and career.
Early on, I struggled with delegation, saying, “I can just do it myself, and I don’t really need anybody’s help.” But it turns out I do need other people’s help. And when you collaborate and work in really high-performing teams, you end up with better solutions than the one you would come up with on your own.
It was probably a little trial and error, finding out that it’s better to work in that environment and then slowly embracing it. I also had to learn about delegation, because I would delegate and then say, “Well, they didn’t end up doing what I was hoping they would do.” But what I found out was that you’ve got to give folks a little bit of a view into your thinking, instead of just saying, “Hey, go do this,” and then hoping they read my mind and come up with what I was thinking. So it wasn’t a failure on their part in delegation; it was on me in setting the parameters for how I wanted them to think about things, and then giving them enough freedom to come back so that I go, “Wow! I didn’t think of it that way, and that’s way better.”
That was a great epiphany for me as I started looking into leadership. As I said, I never really thought of myself as a born leader. I thought, “Well, you must have to have a lot of charisma and just know how to lead.” Well, it turns out you don’t, actually. You can learn leadership, and almost all of us do, and almost all of us can.
Q: How do you keep yourself healthy — physically, mentally, emotionally?
SR: I would start off by saying that I strive to be a servant leader; I don’t really describe myself as one. I’m trying to use those principles to grow in that area. As far as being physically healthy, I’m not always that great at it, to be honest with you. When I get under stress, I tend to eat. So there are stressful times, and there are times that aren’t. There was this little thing called the pandemic, and that did not really help me physically. So I am now trying to do better, and my doctor’s happy, and everybody else is, too.
Emotionally and mentally, though, I’ve always been pretty good, because I really believe in what I do. I have a purpose-driven life, and mission is really important, so that really fuels me and keeps me pretty elevated most of the time. I exercise regularly, probably less for the physical part and more for the mental part. I golf — I golf by myself most of the time, which is a little odd, because it’s not social time for me; it’s alone time, to get with my thoughts. I’m a bit of an introvert by nature, so that helps. And I like to get out and hike in nature and experience beautiful landscapes, usually with my wife, who’s obviously been a great strength.
I also try to stay curious: curious about leadership, and especially curious about what’s going on in the world. So I read a lot. I read leadership books, but I also read literature and other genres, because I think it’s interesting. The world’s really cool out there. And spiritually, I think it’s important as well. I’m pretty connected to my spiritual life and God and prayer, and that actually grounds me probably better than anything else, especially when times are tough.
And my wife, who’s been my steadfast supporter, she will even tell me, “Hey, you probably need to go golfing, because you’re getting a little crazy.” So she understands that the time away is helpful for my mental health.
Q: What’s on your reading list right now?
SR: I recently finished “A Tale of Two Cities.” So that’s not a new one. I’ve read a lot of Dickens, but I hadn’t read that one. I recently read “The Shack,” which is almost 20 years old, but it was very interesting. It has a really nice spiritual and philosophical basis to it. I also read leadership books. I just recently read a book called “Expect a Lot, Care a Lot.” I usually have two or three cracked at one time, and they stimulate different parts of my brain.
Q: What did you learn from “Expect a Lot, Care a Lot”?
SR: It boiled down and synthesized a lot of things you’ve already read. If you read a lot of leadership books, they all have the same sorts of themes and constructs. But the way it was put together, with examples and things, was really good, and it happened to really connect to the leadership philosophy in our organization, which was the nice connection, because we talk about empathy. Emplify Health: empathy amplified. We’re trying to make that a big part of our brand, so we talk about empathy and excellence. You’ve got to have both. You can’t just be empathetic. You also have to have outcomes and expect a lot from people.
A lot of people think there’s a tension between those two things. There’s really not. They’re very compatible and complementary. So when you look at “expect a lot,” which is excellence, and “care a lot,” which is empathy, it really resonated with me.
Q: You mentioned your wife and how important she is in keeping you on the right path, because you’re going to have tough days. When those happen, how important is your wife in that role, and who are the other people you look to in order to move forward?
SR: I tell our leaders that [leadership is] rewarding — you get a lot of fulfillment out of it — but it is difficult, and you can’t tell people it’s easy and no problem. So there can be a fair amount of weighty days sometimes. On my toughest days, your spouse, your life partner, is really great when you’re in harmony. I always feel I can be completely transparent and vulnerable with her, and she’ll help pick me up, and we help pick each other up.
As for other ways, I’ll go back a little bit to my spiritual beliefs. I really believe that God puts us all on the planet for a reason, and we get certain gifts, and we’re meant to use them for good. You can call it God, you can call it the universe, you can call it fate. But I have this belief that I’m not here to chart my own path. I’m here to accept God’s plan and God’s will for the world and for me. So when I have a tough day, it becomes, “Well, what am I supposed to learn from this?” It’s the path I’ve been given, and I need to discern what I’m supposed to get out of it and how I’m supposed to react.
The last piece I’d say — I remember a story from the pandemic. It was tough to lead through, but in some ways it was rewarding. But there were days that were absolutely awful, and my job was to be positive and to be the person saying, “We’re going to make it through, and it’s going to be fine.” But it’s hard when it’s really tough. So on days when it was really bad, I allowed myself to go into my bedroom, close all the blinds so it was completely dark, and wallow in my despair for 15 or 20 minutes. Just go, “Ah, this is terrible,” and wallow in it. And then go, “OK, you’re done. Get up, leave and away you go.” That was actually pretty therapeutic on those tough days, just acknowledge that, yep, it’s really hard, let it wash over you, and then get up and do what needs to be done next.
Q: You mentioned that earlier in your career, delegation was maybe not something that came naturally to you, and you’ve grown into that. In addition to that, what would you say is something you’ve learned about yourself from working in healthcare?
SR: One thing that really hit home — and I probably had too many false starts before I learned this — was that people would come to me as the leader with issues and problems, and my job as a doctor was to fix people’s problems. So I would say [in leadership roles], “OK, let me think about this, and I’ll come up with a plan and a solution.” I did this multiple times. I would come back with a solution that I thought was pretty good, and sometimes it actually was pretty good. Almost universally, people would reject it and be very upset: “Why did you do that?” And I’m like, “Well, I thought you wanted me to solve your problem.”
I finally learned that they didn’t want me to solve their problem. They wanted me to help them solve the problem and to provide them with the resources and the direction and sometimes the time to actually solve it. And wouldn’t you know it, they came up with better solutions than when I was doing it, and they weren’t always my solutions. And people embraced them much better because they had the buy-in. That was probably almost 20 years ago, when I finally asked, “Why are people upset when I’m coming up with pretty good answers for them?”
Once I figured that out, it’s been a much smoother journey, because I engage with folks and I help, but they want to solve their own problems.
Q: Lastly, you mentioned there was some serendipity involved that took you from being a gastroenterologist to a leadership position. In addition to that, is there a risk you’ve taken that’s paid off?
SR: A couple of things. The first one is just investing in leadership — the time and the resources, for myself but also for all of our leaders. They’re working hard every single day. We just had a leadership summit a couple of weeks ago, and that’s a big commitment, to bring 1,100 people together for a couple of days to talk about leadership. Because when leaders get better, everybody benefits. But we’ve got to take the time and make the investment. “Oh, we’ve got to leave our departments and all the chaos that’s going on?” Yes. They’ll be fine. It turns out we still take great care of patients when the leaders are gone for a day. So I think the investment in leadership is a risk, because some people say you can’t distract from the day-to-day. But I think it’s actually paid off in spades in a lot of different ways.
The other one would be: I never really aspired to any of the leadership jobs I had. I was interested, but I became department chair of gastroenterology because no one else wanted to do it, not because they said, “Wow, he’ll be really good at it.” I was elected to our board of governors by my peers. That was nice, that they thought I could do that. I never really thought I would be able to, but someone believed in me. And my prior CEO, who’s kind of my mentor, tapped me on the shoulder and said, “Why don’t you be a medical vice president?” I said, “I don’t think I can do that. I don’t know.” And said, “No, I believe you can.” So there was always somebody else who believed in me.
And then the CEO role opened up. “Well, I’m clearly not CEO material.” This was back in 2015. But they had put me through some leadership training and things, and I thought, “Well, I guess I’m qualified.” And I believe in internal promotion. So I thought, “Well, if qualified people don’t put their hat in the ring, then you never really get it.” Even though I was a dark horse, I went through the process saying, “It doesn’t matter if I get it or I don’t.” Our HR person said, “You can’t tell people that.” I said, “Well, I can always go back and be a gastroenterologist. It’s OK.” [Our HR person repeated:] “You can’t tell people that.” And I was like, “OK, well, I’ll move through the process.”
About halfway through the process, they had a panel one day. I gave an answer, and I went home that night and sat on the couch with my wife and said, “It would have been so much better if I had answered it this way.” And she goes, “Well, I thought you didn’t care about getting this job.” And that really crystallized it: “Well, I guess I do. I do care.”
The transformative piece that was a risk, though, came during that leadership training. I had to make a choice: Do I lead with my head — my brain, which had always been my strength through school and medicine — or do I lead with my heart, which probably wasn’t a great strength? But I had folks in my leadership group saying, “Yeah, I think you’d do better doing that.” And I said, “You’re nuts. There’s no way. I’ve got to be cerebral, right? Logical.” And they said, “No, we think you’d be better off if you led with the heart.” So I did make a conscious choice to do that.
In the last interview for the CEO job, I changed my whole presentation of how I thought the world should look and what I should do. I really took a giant risk there, because I believed that was an interesting change, and I think it probably tipped the scales in my favor and got me selected. And so I’ve lived by that all along; now it’s all about heart. That doesn’t mean you don’t have a brain, but I think you lead from the heart. You support your people. The people are the most important thing.