‘Credibility doesn’t require you to always be right’: How 5 healthcare leaders tackle uncertainty 

Advertisement

Each quarter, Timothy Layman, DNP, RN, opens the doors for a town hall at HSHS St. Mary’s Hospital in Decatur, Ill. Employees ask about everything from whether the cafeteria can stay open later to why benefits costs are going up, and as president and chief administrative officer, he is often asked questions he cannot answer on the spot.

“It’s easy for me to say I don’t know and sit there and pause for a second,” Dr. Layman said. “I think there’s a lot of CEOs, CAOs, presidents that would have trouble doing that.”

Hospital and health system leaders are navigating financial pressures, workforce challenges and policy uncertainty while making decisions that affect employees, patients and the future of their organizations. Executives speaking on two panels at Becker’s 14th Annual CEO+CFO Roundtable in Chicago in November said acknowledging what they do not know can help build credibility, building on similar perspectives other CEOs shared with Becker’s in 2026. They also emphasized that employees are more likely to trust leaders who have established relationships with their teams, communicate openly when circumstances change and make decisions consistent with their organizations’ values.

Credibility is earned before it’s needed

Adria Vanhoozier, vice president of system financial and operational integration at Newport News, Va.-based Riverside Health System, spent about a decade as a hospital CEO before moving into her current system role. She said credibility comes from town halls, regular updates, rounding on units and working night shifts alongside staff, long before a leader has to deliver unwelcome news.

“It’s easier to recover when that forecast changes. It’s harder to recover from a credibility problem,” Ms. Vanhoozier said. “So you’re better to be transparent up front.”

She said that means telling employees what leaders expected to happen, what has changed, what they know and what they do not.

“Credibility doesn’t require you to always be right, but it also requires you to be transparent when that reality changes,” she said.

Ed Jimenez, president and CEO of Radnor, Pa.-based Main Line Health, said he relies on being genuine as the system works to return to strong financial footing through growth, after losing $300 million in the post-pandemic period. But he said leaders do not get to decide whether they meet that standard.

“The judge of that word is the front-line person or the physician you’re recruiting or the existing physicians or the nurses on the night shift,” Mr. Jimenez said. “They’re the barometer of whether you’re genuine or not.”

That view led him to drop structured, scheduled executive rounding. He said a nurse or housekeeper who sees an executive stop by on a set schedule is more likely to think “nice of you to fly by” than if that executive visits without a set schedule and spends time with staff.

Hearing the real answer

Executives also discussed the importance of creating an environment in which employees feel comfortable sharing information and disagreeing with leadership, particularly when decisions involve changes to longstanding operations or care delivery. Jita Buño, who became CEO of University of Washington Medical Center in Seattle about a year ago, said she is still building relationships as the hospital begins capacity management work while running at 98% capacity most mornings.

“I’m realizing that people are sharing with me what they think I want to hear. And trust takes time,” Ms. Buño said. “I can’t wave a wand.”

She said she leads with curiosity and questions, recognizing that employees may not immediately share everything they are thinking with a new leader.

“I am always curious as to what is behind what you are not saying to me,” she said.

Dr. Layman said he makes disagreement a normal part of working at his hospital, where employees can tell him they do not like an idea.

“I love when I get that pushback,” he said.

Roger Mitty, MD, president and COO of Care New England Medical Group in Providence, R.I., said his organization is rolling out high reliability principles, including deference to expertise, which encourages leaders to seek input from employees whose knowledge and experience may differ from their own, including those who do not typically participate in leadership meetings.

“I’ve never run a central sterilization room before and I’ve never been a neurosurgeon before,” he said. “There’s stuff that I just don’t know.”

When actions have to match the message

Leaders said credibility also depends on whether their decisions reflect the values and expectations they communicate to employees. Dr. Mitty described terminating a longtime, high-volume orthopedic surgeon who generated 10,000 to 12,000 relative value units after the surgeon pushed a nurse in the operating room. The physician had previously received counseling for behavioral issues, Dr. Mitty said.

“You cannot make decisions based on what a person brings when there’s a zero tolerance thing, as unpopular as it may be,” Dr. Mitty said. “If you fall down on one part of leadership, you can’t recover from it.”

Dr. Layman said the decision showed employees what high reliability looks like in practice.

For Mr. Jimenez, effective leadership also requires recognizing the limits of one’s own knowledge and remaining open to different approaches as circumstances change.

“We are all victims of what we know,” he said. “Good leaders recognize that pretty often there’s something more, there’s something possibly better or possibly more advanced.”

Advertisement

Next Up in Leadership & Management

Advertisement