‘We cannot replicate what has not worked in the past’: Health systems move away from hospital-centric models

Advertisement

Health systems can no longer rely on acquiring hospitals and expanding traditional service lines to secure their financial futures. As reimbursement pressures mount and consolidation accelerates, CFOs are rethinking where care is delivered, which services should be centralized and how to grow without adding unsustainable costs.

“We cannot replicate what has not worked in the past,” Carlos Bohorquez, CFO of UC San Diego Health, said during a Nov. 3 panel at Becker’s 14th Annual CEO + CFO Roundtable in Chicago. 

Mr. Bohorquez warned that consolidation does not automatically translate into efficiencies, particularly when health systems maintain duplicative leadership structures, staffing and specialty services after bringing hospitals together. On paper, many M&As set out to achieve certain economies of scale, but the reality is that costs often get inflated along the way. 

UC San Diego Health finalized a unique partnership structure in July when it formed a joint powers authority with Escondido, Calif.-based Palomar Health, creating a new health system called Palomar UC San Diego Health. Rather than pursuing a traditional acquisition or merger, the organizations established a new public entity designed to combine Palomar Health’s community hospitals with UC San Diego Health’s academic expertise while allowing both systems to maintain separate licenses and medical staff.

UC San Diego Health finalized a unique partnership with Escondido, Calif.-based Palomar Health in July, forming a joint powers authority that effectively created a new health system, Palomar UC San Diego Health. Rather than pursue a traditional acquisition or merger, the organizations established a public entity that combines Palomar Health’s community hospital footprint with UC San Diego Health’s academic expertise while allowing both systems to maintain separate licenses, medical staffs, boards and leadership teams.

The partnership is designed to stabilize care in the community while giving UC San Diego Health an opportunity to shift lower-acuity patients away from its academic medical centers, freeing capacity for more complex cases.

“Palomar UC San Diego Health creates a new blueprint for healthcare in California,” UC San Diego Health CEO Patty Maysent told Becker’s in a recent interview. “This new system, focused on North San Diego County, will grow and enhance healthcare services while offering increased access to advanced specialty care, close to home.”

However, Mr. Bohorquez said the partnership will not succeed by trying to replicate every service line across every facility. Instead, the organizations are being deliberate about where services should be located and at what level of care, with the goal of building an integrated model that avoids unnecessary duplication.

“We need to be thoughtful as far as where the services should reside, at what level, and that it really is an integrated model that feeds itself as far as what’s the right level of care at the right site and where certain services should be provided,” he said. “Otherwise, we’ll end up with five cardiology programs and little volume at each site, or limited volume, and it’s not going to work.”

Brian Devine, CFO of Allegheny Health Network, echoed that sentiment, arguing that health systems need to move away from capital-intensive hospital models toward more flexible approaches that align care delivery with reimbursement and patient needs.

“We need to move from a hospital-centric model to one that is looking at our own cost and where we can provide the right care in the right setting. And that might be different from where we are today,” Mr. Devine said. “As CFO leaders, that requires us to have harder conversations — challenging conversations about the workforce, sites of care and changing the traditional model to something that’s new.”

Mr. Devine argued that the difficulty is not deciding whether the model needs to change, but determining how far to shift care away from the traditional hospital setting without compromising access or quality.

“The balance is somewhere between maintaining the traditional hospital-centric model that we had and providing care in the community, and probably the patient in the middle of that traveling to certain locations to get the right care at a Center of Excellence,” he said. “It’s a balance we need to strike while we’re navigating all the regulatory changes.”

That shift is already shaping Allegheny Health Network’s growth strategy following its July 1 acquisition of Heritage Valley Health System, a two-hospital network in Western Pennsylvania. Rather than simply adding capacity, the organization is focused on stabilizing operations, integrating technology and revenue cycle processes, and developing service line strategies that complement its existing network.

Mr. Devine said that approach also requires health systems to confront the economics of maintaining underused specialty services across multiple hospitals. In some cases, patients may need to travel to designated centers of excellence for more complex care while other services remain closer to home.

For Craig Collins, senior vice president and CFO of UK HealthCare and CEO of Beyond Blue, building a more integrated operating model following recent acquisitions is also critical to easing capacity constraints.

Mr. Collins said UK HealthCare was operating at 97% capacity in Lexington the morning of the discussion, with 66 patients boarding in its emergency department. The system is exploring partnerships with skilled nursing facilities and other community providers to move patients into appropriate settings and free up beds for those requiring higher-acuity care.

“The biggest opportunity for us — now that we have two more community hospitals — is: Can we take advantage of using them to be able to take care of our patient base?” Mr. Collins said, adding that UK HealthCare was operating at 97% capacity in Lexington the morning of the discussion, with 66 patients boarding in its emergency department.

“We have to figure out a way to get that length of stay down, and then how can we continue to do more and more partnerships with subacute care or send those patients back to a hospital or a care facility that’s closer to home?” he said. “So we’re spending a lot of time trying to build partnerships. 

“I’m working with some SNFs and others where we are dedicating some beds. I’m guaranteeing that we’ll pay for those beds so that we have a place to put patients when they’re ready to go home. It’s a whole new world in trying to be able to get people out. But it is real, and we’ve really got to start to look at that as an opportunity.”

UK HealthCare has expanded through its integration of King’s Daughters in Ashland, Ky., and St. Claire in Morehead, Ky., while pursuing shared services and technology standardization to support growth without proportionate increases in staffing. 

Still, Mr. Collins acknowledged that integration can present unexpected operational challenges, including the difficulty of transitioning hospitals with heavily customized EHR systems onto a common platform.

UK HealthCare invested $95 million into rolling out Epic and Workday software this year, a move that aims to unify operations and improve patient care across the health system. It is also implementing identity access management to improve efficiency, data management and patient outcomes. 

“It’s a big investment to do this, but the outcomes, the quality and the opportunity to have shared data across the Commonwealth on our patients is one of the reasons that we’re doing this,” he said. “We’re really having the opportunity to touch patients and to manage their care differently. We’re going back to the basics in many ways around cost containment and around process improvement.”

Advertisement

Next Up in Financial Management

Advertisement