Nearly 88% of ED nurses faced workplace violence in a single month: Study

Advertisement

Nearly 88% of emergency department nurses reported experiencing workplace violence in the previous month, according to a study published Nov. 13 in JAMA Network Open.

Researchers led by Wake Forest University School of Medicine in Winston-Salem, N.C., surveyed nurses working in 11 EDs across a multisite health system spanning two states in the Southeast. The survey ran from Jan. 31, 2023, to March 6, 2023. Of the 758 nurses invited, 337 made up the final sample. 

The researchers linked survey responses with administrative and electronic medical record data. Workplace violence (WPV) included threats, physical violence, verbal abuse, unwanted sexual attention and bullying from patients, visitors or co-workers.

“The prevalence of WPV observed in this study underscores the extent to which WPV is embedded in the routine work experiences of ED nurses, where WPV appears to be the norm rather than the exception,” the authors wrote.

Here are five things to know from the study:

1. Of the 337 nurses surveyed, 296 (87.8%) reported at least one form of workplace violence in the previous month. Nearly all of them (98.6%) experienced violence from patients or visitors.

2. Verbal abuse was the most common form of violence from patients or visitors, reported by 95.2% of nurses who experienced it from those sources. Threats of violence (71.9%) and physical violence (34.6%) followed. 

3. One in five nurses who experienced workplace violence (20.3%) reported it from co-workers, most often as bullying. The authors noted that many health system surveillance programs focus on severe physical violence and may miss these behaviors.

4. Nurses who worked overtime had more than three times the odds of experiencing workplace violence compared with those who did not. The study’s cross-sectional design means researchers could not determine whether overtime raises the risk or whether violence drives turnover and creates more overtime.

5. Night shift and work at a freestanding ED were associated with lower odds of workplace violence, compared with day shift and in-hospital EDs, respectively. In unadjusted analyses, nurses in EDs with higher satisfaction, psychological safety, teamwork, manager support and physical safety scores also reported lower odds of violence.

The authors said the findings support adding work-hour metrics to workplace violence prevention programs and tailoring strategies to specific ED settings. In an accompanying commentary, emergency medicine researchers from the Indiana University School of Medicine in Indianapolis questioned that emphasis. They argued the overtime link likely reflects more time spent in the ED, and that the study’s findings “do not justify restricting or eliminating” overtime.

Advertisement

Next Up in Workforce

Advertisement