Hospitals and health systems are redefining what nurse competency looks like and how it’s tracked at their facilities.
There is no standard definition of nurse competency, leaders told Becker’s, but all of competency’s definitions have common elements: knowledge, skills, abilities and judgment. However, what makes up those elements changes by the particular hospital and specialty.
“That’s part of what made our own work hard,” Toni Haddox, RN, vice president of nursing professional development & practice excellence at Salt Lake City-based Intermountain Health, told Becker’s.
The differing definitions of competency
Every system has created a unique definition of competency, but they all serve the same purpose: being clear about what competency means in practice.
“A nurse may be able to demonstrate a procedure in a controlled environment, but competent practice also requires knowing when to use it, when not to use it, how to adapt when the situation changes and when to escalate a concern,” Alicia Potolsky, DNP, RN, associate chief nursing officer at Mountain View, Calif.-based El Camino Health, told Becker’s. “Ultimately, competency is about reliable performance when it matters most.”
Over the past four years, Cedars-Sinai has established four competency tiers and specialty-specific requirements for clinical nurses, David Marshall, JD, DNP, RN, senior vice president and chief nursing executive at the Los Angeles-based system, told Becker’s.
Roseville, Calif.-based Adventist Health rebuilt nurse competency checks to scrap the check-the-box competency fair for a dyad model that grades new nurses on two metrics: how well they document care, and whether they can actually perform the clinical skill in front of an evaluator.
Intermountain Health anchored its definition in two sources: Donna Wright’s definition, “the ability to perform one’s job responsibilities correctly, safely and according to standards,” and the Association for Nursing Professional Development’s standard, which frames competency as “the integration and application of knowledge, skills, attitudes and critical thinking necessary to perform a specific nursing role or task safely and effectively.” Leaders also made a distinction between competence and competency.
“We also draw a hard line between competence (an ability acquired through experience and learning) and competency (the applied, verifiable demonstration of that ability in a specific role),” Ms. Haddox said. “The most important shift in our language is that competency is verification of performance, not attendance or knowledge acquisition — education can get someone to competence, but it isn’t competence itself.”
Where competency remains consistent across systems
Although the definitions of competency vary, competency structures, workforce implications and ownership are consistent around the country.
1. Models are moving from a completion- to a readiness-based approach. Although checklists, annual education and skills validation maintain a role in competency tracking, many systems are moving away from these models to find more dynamic ways of showing competency. This includes reinforcing learning through real-time observations, coaching during patient care, case reviews, unit-level data, peer education, discussing the rationale behind clinical decisions, and annual skills fair for low-volume, high-intensity skills that need routine refreshers, leaders said.
“The shift for me has been from thinking primarily about whether education or a skill validation was completed to asking whether we can demonstrate readiness and reliable practice,” Dr. Potolsky said. “The biggest gap is often between documenting exposure and demonstrating application. A completed module, checklist or validation tells us that something occurred at a point in time. It does not necessarily tell us how a nurse will respond when a patient deteriorates, when the clinical picture is ambiguous or when the expected sequence no longer applies.”
2. Competency is becoming a workforce lever, not just a compliance task. Competency is increasingly interconnected with recruitment, retention and staffing, leaders told Becker’s.
“The question is not simply whether we have enough nurses,” Dr. Potolsky said. “It is whether we are developing a workforce that is prepared to grow, adapt and deliver safe, reliable care in increasingly complex environments.”
After Intermountain Health merged with SCL Health in 2022, leaders discovered they were spending roughly $1.9 million in maintaining competency management across three legacy approaches, and 66% of that was rebuilding the same competencies in parallel.
“That discovery reframed competency from a compliance task into a workforce-capacity issue,” Ms. Haddox said. “We’ve since tied it directly to retention and staffing metrics: since consolidating, we’ve oriented 18% more RNs year over year while cutting average orientation hours per RN by about 6% and shortening orientation by roughly two weeks on average. Less time spent on redundant checklists means more time for preceptors to coach, and that is a direct lever on new-nurse retention and staffing capacity, not a side benefit.”
Intermountain Health also halted roughly 90% of their skills fairs because “we were doing more education than actual competency validation,” Ms. Haddox said. Instead, they adopted an annual-fair/checklist model and capped unit-identified competencies at six or fewer per unit per year to focus on staying meaningful. Every competency is required to have at least two verification methods, with methods tied to observed performance and reasoning being the most trusted.
3. Judgment and critical thinking remain the hardest competencies to prove. Leaders are finding new ways to gather evidence for judgment and critical thinking competencies, the most difficult to prove. The strongest evidence comes from performance in context, leaders told Becker’s.
“We do case discussions so we can make reasoning visible to an observer,” Dr. Marshall said.
“We have a very robust simulation center here at Cedars-Sinai and we make sure we have clear assessor roles and preceptor roles. If we identify a practice gap, we develop a learning plan for it and help the person with that competency.”
Intermountain uses an AI platform to assess new nurses on scenario-based case studies.
Adventist Health also uses scenario-based studies that identified gaps in knowledge and leaned on experienced staff to act as per diem educators.
4. Competency ownership is shared. At all of the systems Becker’s talked to, competency is a shared responsibility across frontline nurses and leadership. Nurses are accountable to maintain their competency, while professional development units own the structure and unit leaders are responsible for evidence collection.