Judge tosses 4-year visa cap for international physicians in training

Advertisement

A federal judge on Nov. 16 struck down a Homeland Security Department rule that would have limited international medical residents and fellows to four-year stays, entering a final judgment that vacates the rule.

Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts granted summary judgment to a coalition of higher education groups and labor unions, finding the rule arbitrary and capricious and contrary to law under the Administrative Procedure Act, according to court documents reviewed by Becker’s.

The rule would have replaced the decades-old “duration of status” system, which lets F, J and I visa holders stay for the length of their program, with fixed admission periods of four years for students and exchange visitors and 240 days for foreign journalists. However, many training programs run longer, which means residents would have needed to file for an extension midway through training to finish, a decision the rule left to DHS’ discretion with no right of appeal. General surgery residencies take five years, and neurosurgery takes seven. 

The change would have affected nearly 17,000 physicians in residency and fellowship programs nationwide, according to the American Hospital Association.

Mr. Saylor, who blocked the rule Sept. 14, adopted his earlier findings that DHS failed to weigh costs and benefits, failed to support its fraud and national security rationale and ignored less burdensome alternatives. He added that DHS never adequately considered strengthening the existing Student and Exchange Visitor Information System, which already requires schools and program sponsors to report on visa holders.

He also found that the rule’s limits on academic programs exceed the agency’s statutory authority. The law “simply does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority to undermine the F-1 visa program,” Mr. Saylor said.

DHS had asked the court to send the rule back to the agency without vacating it. Mr. Saylor declined, noting the current system has existed for decades and the rule never took effect.

DHS’ appeal of the September injunction remains pending before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 1st Circuit.

Becker’s has reached out to DHS for comment and will update this story if more information becomes available.

Advertisement

Next Up in Integration & Physician Issues

Advertisement