Two surgeons say CMS treats gains in surgical efficiency as less work and pays less for them.
They told Becker’s the 2027 physician fee schedule, finalized Nov. 4, ignores the team-based work that makes shorter procedures and same-day care possible.
The final rule cuts the conversion factor 2.31% to $32.63 for physicians not in a qualifying advanced alternative payment model. That is deeper than the 1.68% cut CMS proposed in July. The rule also keeps the 2.5% “efficiency adjustment,” which took effect in 2026 and cut work RVUs and intraservice time for about 7,700 non-time-based codes. The American College of Surgeons has said the data contradicts the adjustment. It cited a study of 1.7 million operations that found operative times rose 3.1% from 2019 to 2023.
Shorter cases, more work around them
Charles Taunt, DO, a hip and knee replacement surgeon at Michigan Orthopedic Center in Lansing, said operating time and length of stay for hip and knee replacements have both dropped. He said that efficiency depends on a large team working before and after the operation. Nurses, medical assistants and advanced practice providers educate patients, prepare them for surgery, set expectations, answer questions and check on them at home.
Much of that work used to happen while patients recovered in a hospital bed. Now practice staff do it, Dr. Taunt told Becker’s.
CMS’ payment for those procedures reflects the shorter hospital stays. The final rule cuts work RVUs for total hip and total knee replacement 12.6%, from 19.11 to 16.70. That lowers the work portion of each case from about $638 to about $545 before geographic adjustment. CMS had proposed cuts closer to 20%.
The values came from AMA survey data in which total physician time fell to 305 minutes from more than six hours. Medicare data also showed the procedures were performed inpatient less than half the time from 2021 to 2023. Orthopedic groups argued that the work moved to practices rather than disappearing.
“All of that takes significant time and effort to run those teams, to build those teams, to foster those teams,” Dr. Taunt said. “I don’t think that they’re giving value to the work product that’s being done that isn’t counted in minutes or hours of face-to-face patient care. I think that’s where the disconnect is.”
Dr. Taunt previously told Becker’s the combined cuts top 20% over two years.
Same-day care treated as duplication
Thomas Tsai, MD, medical director for health policy research in the American College of Surgeons’ Division of Advocacy and Health Policy, pointed to the final rule’s change to modifier 25. Physicians use the modifier to bill a significant, separately identifiable evaluation and management (E/M) service on the same day as a procedure. About 50 million of 220 million Medicare office and outpatient E/M visits in 2024 carried the modifier.
CMS proposed paying 50% less for the lower-valued same-day service, citing “likely” duplicate payment for overlapping work. That proposal covered 0-, 10- and 90-day global procedures. The final rule sets a 20% reduction instead. It applies only to 0-day global procedures, billed by the same physician or a same-specialty physician in the same group. A Jiro Health analysis of the proposal found private practices and solo physicians would absorb 81.5% of the modeled $889 million in reductions.
Same-day care is more convenient for patients, Dr. Tsai said, but it takes more of the physician’s schedule and needs staff support, such as a medical assistant for procedures done in the office.
“Medicare is mistaking that for duplication of effort,” he said. “Streamlining care should not equate to reduced payment.”
Who absorbs the cost
Dr. Taunt said his practice’s physician partners have absorbed recent cuts by taking pay cuts, while staff wages, health insurance and supply costs went up. If cuts continue, he said, the practice may hold down wage increases, leave open positions unfilled and use AI to triage patient calls.
“Ultimately, I think there’s going to be less humans in the office to interact with patients, to do their education, to manage their intake, to answer their questions, to greet them,” he said.
Dr. Tsai said the yearly changes are adding up.
“It is truly death by 1,000 cuts to the medical profession,” he said.