What happens after immediate jeopardy: CMS’ process from survey to termination

Advertisement

When CMS or state surveyors cite a hospital with immediate jeopardy, the hospital’s Medicare agreement — and with it most of its revenue — is suddenly on a timer measured in weeks.

Immediate jeopardy is the most serious deficiency finding federal regulators can issue. It triggers a compressed enforcement process that ends in one of two places: the hospital fixes the problem, or it loses the Medicare and Medicaid funding that keeps most hospitals operating.

Here is what happens between that finding and a termination notice.

What immediate jeopardy means

Immediate jeopardy is a situation in which a hospital’s noncompliance with one or more Medicare conditions of participation “has caused or is likely to cause serious injury, harm, impairment or death,” according to CMS’ State Operations Manual.

To cite it, surveyors must affirm three elements, per CMS’ Appendix Q guidance: 

1. Noncompliance, meaning the hospital failed to meet one or more federal health, safety or quality rules.

2. Serious harm, actual or probable, to at least one patient. Actual harm need not to have occurred.

3. Immediacy, meaning the situation requires immediate action to prevent serious harm from occurring or recurring. One at-risk patient is enough, and death always meets the harm threshold.

How regulators deem a hospital to be in immediate jeopardy

The finding comes out of a survey — often an unannounced inspection triggered by a complaint, though it can also surface during a routine recertification survey or one tied to a reported event.

Surveyors spend time on-site reviewing records, observing care and interviewing staff. When they identify immediate jeopardy, they notify hospital leadership before they leave, typically at an exit conference, and document the findings in a statement of deficiencies called Form CMS-2567.

The 2567 is the official account of what surveyors found and the regulation each finding violates. It is also the document the hospital must answer.

The timeline

Once immediate jeopardy is cited, the hospital is on what CMS calls the 23-day termination track. CMS issues a preliminary notice that the hospital’s Medicare agreement will end in 23 days unless the hospital removes the immediate jeopardy or successfully disputes the finding. If the jeopardy is not resolved, CMS sends a final notice two to four days before the termination date.

Removing immediate jeopardy is not the same as a full fix. The hospital submits a removal plan — the immediate actions it has taken or will take to protect patients from the specific harm. Unlike a full plan of correction, the removal plan does not have to correct all of the underlying noncompliance; it has to eliminate the likelihood of serious harm.

CMS approval of that plan does not, by itself, lift the jeopardy. Surveyors must return on-site and verify the plan is fully implemented. A remote or telephone review is not allowed. Only then is immediate jeopardy considered removed.

Removing the jeopardy stops the 23-day clock but does not end the process. The hospital still receives the CMS-2567 and must submit a plan of correction addressing the remaining deficiencies, and surveyors conduct a later revisit to confirm the hospital is back in substantial compliance.

When deficiencies are serious but do not rise to immediate jeopardy, hospitals move more slowly: CMS allows up to 90 days to return to compliance, with at least 15 days’ notice before any termination. 

What termination does

For a hospital, losing its Medicare agreement is close to a death sentence, as Medicare and Medicaid cover a large share of hospital patients. 

CMS must publish public notice of the termination at the same time it notifies the hospital, stating the reasons, the effective date and how patients’ care will be handled. Medicare generally stops paying for patients admitted on or after the effective date, though it may keep covering inpatients admitted beforehand for up to 30 more days.

Hospitals can appeal a termination through a federal administrative process, but the agreement generally ends on schedule while the appeal proceeds.

Unlike nursing homes, which face a plethora of intermediate penalties such as fines and payment suspensions, hospitals have essentially two choices: return to compliance or lose the agreement.

Why a termination rarely happens

Full closure is rare, but it happens. Galesburg (Ill.) Cottage Hospital shut its doors in January 2022, days before CMS terminated its Medicare agreement over serious patient safety deficiencies — including missed safety checks and unmonitored restraints — with its CEO attributing the closure directly to the loss of federal funding.

Termination is the exception. The 23-day track is built to force a fast fix, and most hospitals remove the jeopardy and correct the underlying problems well before the deadline. Termination typically follows only when a hospital cannot or does not resolve the deficiencies in time.

Advertisement

Next Up in Legal & Regulatory Issues

Advertisement