EHR nudges fail to curb unneeded cataract surgery tests at UCLA Health

Advertisement

Behavioral science-based EHR nudges did not significantly reduce low-value preoperative testing before cataract surgery at Los Angeles-based UCLA Health, according to a randomized clinical trial published Nov. 5 in JAMA Ophthalmology.

Randomized trials have shown that routine testing before cataract surgery does not improve outcomes, and professional societies have long recommended against it. Still, most cataract surgery patients get at least one preoperative test.

Researchers randomly assigned physicians who perform preoperative evaluations to usual care or to one of three interruptive EHR alerts. Each alert cited professional society recommendations against routine testing. Each also stressed a different harm to patients: no safety benefit, financial burden or psychological stress.

The trial enrolled patients from June 24, 2021, to April 11, 2023. Of 776 randomized physicians, 229 had at least one eligible encounter. Those encounters totaled 1,045 preoperative visits with 967 patients, whose average age was 72.

Testing rates fell from 83% to 79% in the nudge groups. In the control group, rates fell from 84% to 82%. The difference was not statistically significant.

Secondary analyses suggested some effect. Sixteen percent of orders were canceled after a nudge appeared, and the psychological stress alert was linked to fewer complete blood count and electrocardiogram orders.

The research team was led by Catherine Sarkisian, MD, of the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA. The authors concluded that the results do not support using EHR nudges to reduce preoperative testing. They suggested future studies test the psychological stress nudge together with behavioral, workflow or payment changes.

Advertisement

Next Up in Digital Health

Advertisement