Illinois officials have declined to provide additional financial aid to Reno, Nev.-based American Healthcare Systems’ Waukegan, Ill.-based Vista Medical Center East and Granite City, Ill.-based Gateway Regional Medical Center.
Medical committees at both hospitals had asked Gov. JB Pritzker’s office the week of Nov. 9 for $9 million to help take partial control of the struggling hospitals, warning that they could close before the holidays without “immediate” help, the Chicago Tribune reported Nov. 16.
In a Nov. 17 letter obtained by Becker’s and addressed to AHS’ president and CEO Michael Sarian, PhD, chief legal officer Ann Lawrence and the Chicago Medical Society CEO Ted Kanellakes, state leaders said they “share the sentiment” regarding concern for patient healthcare access, but after review, the state is unable to fulfill AHS’ financial request.
The letter comes after CMS said Nov. 16 that it will end its Medicare agreement with Vista Medical Dec. 1. CMS cited Vista Medical’s inability to meet four Medicare conditions of participation for hospitals: governing body, anesthesia services, emergency services and physical environment. Moreover, due to struggles with payroll, the two hospitals are also on “bypass” status, meaning ambulances are sent to other facilities, which has resulted in low patient census.
“These findings are deeply concerning and reflect longstanding operational, financial and patient safety issues that have persisted despite repeated opportunities for corrective action,” the state letter said. “The state shares CMS’ significant concerns about governance at the hospitals. Over the last three years, Vista has had five different CEOs, while Gateway has had at least three. As of this communication, it is unclear who is responsible for the day-to-day operations at Vista, and there appears to be no continuity in management and proper oversight.”
The state’s letter questioned AHS’ plan to name new, independent leadership, given that one of its two “new” leaders is AHS’ current legal counsel and adviser. “We have reason to believe this ‘proposal’ is in fact orchestrated by AHS, which is funded by private equity and can easily access needed capital,” the letter said. “This raises significant concerns about the new, allegedly ‘independent’ and physician-led structure.”
A spokesperson for AHS said in a Nov. 17 statement shared with Becker’s that the company is “deeply disappointed” with the state’s decision, and corrected the letter in saying that AHS is not owned or funded by private equity.
“Our priority is the safety of our patients and the welfare of the medical providers and staff who continue to care for this community under extraordinarily difficult conditions,” the AHS spokesperson said. “We will continue to work with the IDPH to pursue every available option to preserve services in Waukegan and Granite City.”
The state further said it had given millions to both Vista Medical and Gateway since AHS acquired them in 2023 through “advance loans and other support.” It said AHS’ proposal also came without detailed plans for how its money would support the hospitals and said they learned about the letter from news coverage prior to receiving it.
AHS presented a plan for financial turnaround at the hospitals that never materialized after its acquisition, did not make repayments on loans that were provided and owes Illinois nearly $120 million in unpaid taxes and penalties, the letter added.
The state’s letter also lists problems at both hospitals that have required repeated state involvement since AHS acquired them:
- Decisions affecting service lines like anesthesia, emergency services and the late October loss of Vista’s level 2 trauma designation;
- Deficiencies found through state and federal oversight, including the CMS termination notice;
- Late payments to critical vendors, including the blood bank, lab vendors and utilities; and
- Failure to make payroll every pay period and to keep essential staff.
“We are also deeply troubled by how staff have been treated at both hospitals,” the letter said. “AHS has weaponized payrolls, pressuring the state on multiple occasions to fund payrolls, claiming no funds were available. Only when state funds were not provided, did AHS fund — or partially fund — payroll with available resources. While the state is concerned about workforce stability, the state is not obligated or able to provide a last-minute financial bailout when AHS continuously fails to manage its operational problems.”
The state said both hospitals will remain on bypass due to the existing “inability to reliably and consistently pay staff physicians and resolve uncertainty concerning payroll cycles.”
Vista Health System said in a Nov. 17 LinkedIn post that keeping Vista Medical open is about more than preserving the building, but also about protecting lives, ensuring community care access and maintaining emergency services.
Vista said closing the hospital could add approximately 20 minutes to the time some patients need to reach cardiac and stroke treatment. Approximately 18% of its patients are also self-pay, with nearly 20% of them undocumented.
“Closing doesn’t eliminate the need for healthcare- it simply makes access harder, may delay treatment, and shifts the burden onto neighboring hospitals,” the system said in its post. “We are asking the state of Illinois to invest in preserving this essential community resource through targeted funding, transparency, and financial accountability- not without recognition of the aid previously given, but with the understanding that these funds have targeted use and would solely allow for the hospital to remain operational during a restructure.”
The state’s letter said it remains “willing to work in good faith toward a credible long-term solution,” but cannot justify added public investment in a proposal that prolongs the existing crisis.