The financial gap between high and low performing hospitals is growing, according to Kaufman Hall’s most recent “National Hospital Flash Report,” released Nov. 17.
“The margin gap between higher- and lower-performing hospitals has widened to 19 percentage points, with a historically large portion of hospitals operating at negative or very thin margins,” said the authors of the report, which factors in data from the last eight years. “Even slight revenue reductions threaten organizations, which face increasingly difficult decisions on future operations, care delivery and expense control.”
The report is based on Strata’s data gathered from more than 2,300 organizations in September. Overall hospital margins continued a downward trend, dipping to 2.4% from 3% the month before while payer mix, rising bad debt and charity care as well as expense growth hit hospitals hard.
The operating margin was flat year over year as net operating revenue per calendar day was up 6% and total expenses per calendar day rose 5% year over year. Drug expenses grew the most, at 9% compared to the same time last year, and bad debt and charity care per calendar day increased 16%.
Hospital executives are keeping a close eye on the bad debt and charity care rates ahead of 2027, when more changes from HR 1 are scheduled to go into effect. The changes are expected to decrease Medicaid eligibility and narrow subsidies with ACA marketplace plans, which will leave more people uninsured and underinsured. The American Hospital Association released a report in October noting the Medicaid service and federal spending reductions could put 300-plus hospitals at risk of closure.
The financial performance varied by hospital location and size. Hospitals in the west saw better performance, with a 27% year over year margin increase while hospitals in the South reported a 5% average margin drop. Smaller hospitals experienced a slight margin dip year over year while hospitals with 500+ beds reported margins dropped nearly 14% in September.
But there are levers hospitals can pull to help build financial resilience, according to Kaufman Hall.
“The ongoing migration to outpatient, along with other reimbursement pressures, reinforce the importance of organizations taking a holistic view of operations, including coverage, payer mix, utilization, revenue, cost, service portfolios and community needs,” the report notes. “Strategic decisions made now will help shape how organizations are positioned for the future.”