For Bob Riney, president and CEO of Detroit-based Henry Ford Health, the main challenge with respect to healthcare financing is not a lack of efforts to address it, but that those efforts have not resolved the underlying structural issues.
Mr. Riney has made that case before. He told Becker’s in February that policy responses such as the 340B drug pricing program and critical access payments have worked as short-term stabilizers without creating a permanent reset for healthcare economics. During a fireside chat at Becker’s CEO + CFO Roundtable on Nov. 4, he expanded on that argument.
“The fundamental structural challenge is the industry has built great success on a model that’s no longer economically feasible,” he said.
Mr. Riney credited the fee-for-service model with producing highly skilled specialists and high-quality care for patients facing critical illness. But he said the same model has focused on crisis care at the expense of serving as a health partner over the course of a person’s life, and he pointed to spending as an example of that imbalance. Developed countries with advanced health systems spend 15% to 17% of healthcare dollars on prevention and primary care, he said, compared with about 7% in the U.S. Henry Ford is now at roughly 10% and working to increase that share, according to Mr. Riney.
He said the need for broader changes is becoming more apparent as healthcare affordability remains a concern for Americans. Ahead of the midterm elections, 88% of registered voters said healthcare costs would have at least some impact on their decision to vote, while 91% said those costs would influence which party’s candidate they supported, according to an April KFF poll.
Mr. Riney said he expects healthcare affordability to remain a significant issue for state leaders following the elections. While he welcomed the attention to healthcare costs, he also expressed concern that competing stakeholder interests could make broader changes to the financing system difficult to achieve.
“I’m worried that even our political process will push us down a path where every unique stakeholder in healthcare is just going to continue to fight and fight and lobby to preserve their piece of the pie. And we’re not going to solve any problem and then we’re going to have it solved for us because it’ll just be [endemic] from a cost standpoint,” he said.
Mr. Riney also proposed testing different financing and care delivery models across entire communities before considering broader adoption.
“I’d like to see a combination of federal and state adopt four or five pilot models. And I’m not talking pilot at a surface level, I’m talking about taking entire communities, and pilot a radically different way to organize healthcare financing and healthcare delivery,” Mr. Riney said.
For those pilots to work, he said, federal and state governments would need to provide financial protections for participating organizations over a defined period. He said such protections could encourage pharmaceutical companies, insurers, health systems, suppliers, healthcare innovators and other stakeholders to participate in testing new models without having to absorb the full financial risks associated with changing their existing arrangements.
“The only way you’re going to get them to the table in a really big way is if there’s kind of a protective bubble for X number of years to really define what works and what doesn’t and pick very different markets,” he said.
Mr. Riney suggested selecting communities with different demographic and health profiles to evaluate how various approaches perform under varying circumstances. He would like Southeast Michigan to be considered as one of the potential test sites.
“I don’t think this country is ready for a single payer system, especially the ramifications that come with that,” he said. “But we know that we can’t keep going with what we are.”
Mr. Riney said policymakers have generally responded to financial pressures by addressing individual issues rather than pursuing broader changes to the financing model.
“Healthcare finance was broke, and so what’s happened at both the state and federal level is patches were put on a patch for rural hospitals, a patch for essential urban hospitals, a patch through 340B, a patch for this, a patch for that,” he said. “And now of course the strategy has been, because of the pressures, to rip some of those patches off. The patches didn’t solve the problem, and removing the patches aren’t going to fix the problem. Only really sitting down and redesigning is going to fix the problem.”
At Henry Ford, the system has been pursuing value-based care arrangements for years, including through its Mosaic clinically integrated network. Mr. Riney said the system manages about 600,000 people through a fully capitated model, which he described as an opportunity to evaluate different approaches to care delivery and financing. Henry Ford also owns a health plan, allowing it to examine costs across the organization, and is pursuing similar value-based arrangements with other insurers. The system also has direct-to-employer arrangements with General Motors for salaried employees and a relationship with DTE Energy, a Detroit-based energy company.
Mr. Riney said the work has elevated the role of primary care physicians within Henry Ford and increased patients’ engagement in their own care, although he acknowledged that progress has taken time. The system is working to demonstrate that value-based care can improve outcomes and manage costs over time while continuing to provide complex specialty care, an approach he said some organizations question whether health systems can successfully balance.
Henry Ford is also navigating significant financial pressures. Mr. Riney said the system’s annual uncompensated care and coverage has reached approximately $1.1 billion, compared with about $900 million previously. Rather than reducing its presence in communities with significant healthcare needs, he said, Henry Ford has diversified its operations through retail pharmacy, retail optical services, an innovation institute that develops startup companies and geographic expansion intended to balance its payer mix.
The system is also investing $2.2 billion in its Detroit campus as part of a larger transformation. Mr. Riney said Henry Ford has increased its advocacy at the state and federal levels to emphasize the financial challenges facing health systems that serve populations with substantial unmet healthcare needs.
While those strategies have helped Henry Ford operate within the existing financing structure, Mr. Riney said more substantial changes are needed.
“I’m going to keep pushing the most daunting approach because I think the incremental stuff is why we’re here in the situation we are,” he said.