Half of US nonprofit hospitals get more in tax breaks than they give back: Report

Advertisement

Among U.S. nonprofit hospitals, 52% get more in tax breaks than they spend on charity care and community investment, according to a Nov. 17 analysis from the Lown Institute. 

The Lown Institute examined 3,037 hospitals across 50 states and the District of Columbia, using fiscal year 2023 data from IRS Form 990, CMS hospital cost reports and local property assessment portals. It then compared each hospital’s tax exemption value with its spending in five community benefit categories reported on Form 990: financial assistance, subsidized health services, community health improvement services, cash and in-kind contributions, and community building activities. The analysis called the difference “fair share spending.”

The five categories are the only community benefit spending the analysis counted, so hospitals could be investing more in ways the analysis did not capture. Lown most notably excluded the Medicaid shortfall, which makes up nearly half of all community benefit spending hospitals report.

“Hospital losses on Medicaid patients is not funding that goes into the community to improve health,” the analysis said. “It is an accounting measure, not direct spending.”  

Lown’s analysis also excluded health professions education, research and contributions to affiliated medical schools, physician groups and other hospitals. The analysis said that hospital cost reports are not required to be audited by independent accounting firms, so reported income may be inaccurate, and that property values in certain states were unavailable and had to be imputed.

Hospitals with a deficit received $27.5 billion in tax exemptions and gave back $12 billion, a net shortfall of $15.5 billion to communities. Hospitals that had a surplus received $11.3 billion in tax exemptions and gave back $25.1 billion, a net benefit of $13.8 billion to communities.

California, Florida, Illinois and Ohio saw statewide fair share deficits that exceeded $1 billion. The analysis said nonprofit hospitals hold $240 billion in real estate, which exceeds the assessed value of all taxable property in Colorado. 

“Some of America’s wealthiest hospitals fall hundreds of millions short of giving back what they receive from their communities, leaving those with fewer resources to pick up the slack,” Vikas Saini, MD, president of the Lown Institute, said in a release shared with Becker’s. “Tax exemptions aren’t a gift — they’re an expectation, and regulators need to make sure all hospitals hold up their end of the bargain.”

Here are the 10 hospitals with the largest fair share deficits:

  1. Mayo Clinic Hospital (Rochester, Minn.): $366 million
  2. Tisch Hospital (New York City): $294 million
  3. Stanford (Calif.) Hospital: $255 million
  4. New York-Presbyterian Hospital (New York City): $248 million
  5. Massachusetts General Hospital (Boston): $219 million
  6. IU Health Methodist Hospital (Indianapolis): $216 million
  7. Orlando (Fla.) Regional Medical Center: $208 million
  8. Nationwide Children’s Hospital (Columbus, Ohio): $191 million
  9. Inova Fairfax Hospital (Falls Church, Va.): $141 million
  10. Cleveland Clinic Main Campus: $140 million

Here are the 10 hospitals with the largest fair share surpluses:

  1. North Shore University Hospital (Manhasset, N.Y.): $167 million
  2. Rochester (N.Y.) General Hospital: $146 million
  3. Englewood (N.J.) Hospital: $142 million
  4. One Brooklyn Health (New York City): $136 million
  5. Hackensack (N.J.) University Medical Center: $124 million
  6. Sanford USD Medical Center (Sioux Falls, S.D.): $103 million
  7. New York-Presbyterian Queens (Flushing, N.Y.): $102 million
  8. Strong Memorial Hospital (Rochester, N.Y.): $101 million
  9. St. Joseph’s University Medical Center (Paterson, N.J.): $100 million
  10. Barnes-Jewish Hospital (St. Louis): $95 million

Lown recommended that policymakers strengthen charity care standards, tighten community benefit reporting requirements and set minimum spending targets for community investment.

“In the long term, the way that we pay hospitals needs to be transformed,” the analysis said. “The current system is unsustainable for many hospitals, encourages more services over keeping people healthy, values privately insured patients above those with public insurance and high-margin elective procedures above preventive care. Our market-based system also rewards hospitals for being bigger and more consolidated with higher prices, resulting in greater costs for everyone.”

Hospital organizations have historically pushed back on the Lown Institute’s fair share analysis. 

In a Nov. 20 blog post, the American Hospital Association criticized the report and said Lown “uses an artificially narrow measure of community benefit to argue that nonprofit hospitals are falling short, while ignoring billions of dollars in benefits that hospitals provide to their communities.”

The association pointed to an EY analysis of IRS data that found nonprofit hospitals provided approximately $149 billion in community benefits in 2022, compared with $13.2 billion in federal tax exemptions. Even with an estimated $41.1 billion in state and local tax exemptions, hospitals provided nearly three times as much in community benefits as they received in total tax exemptions, AHA said.

AHA also cited rising uninsured rates and coverage losses expected under HR 1.

“Hospitals and health systems of all kinds, sizes and locations will continue to care for these patients while also absorbing significant chronic underpayments from government programs,” the AHA post said. “This reality facing hospitals and patients deserves far more attention than another incomplete assessment from Lown that neither helps policymakers address the root cause of the problem nor offers workable solutions.”

Advertisement

Next Up in Financial Management

Advertisement