CMS released a proposed rule for contract year 2028 that would change how Medicare Advantage plans enter markets, establish provider networks and earn star ratings. The proposal also includes a new mandatory, state-based payment model.
The agency said the changes aim to increase competition and beneficiary choice in a program covering more than 35 million people.
Six things to know:
1. CMS wants to shrink the star ratings measure set. The ratings would focus on 15 measures, with an emphasis on clinical outcomes and patient experience. CMS also proposed methodology changes that would make it harder to earn high ratings and the quality bonus payments tied to them. The proposal comes as at least 16 insurers are suing CMS over their 2027 star ratings. The insurers argue the agency used measures that were never adopted through notice-and-comment rulemaking, and together they say their ratings will cost them more than $4.1 billion in lost bonus payments.
2. The CMS Innovation Center’s ADVaNCE MA model would launch in select states in 2029 and run for 10 years. The model would test quality incentives, allow plans to target certain supplemental benefits to low-income subsidy enrollees and test a new risk adjustment methodology through shadow testing. CMS is also considering a future carve-out of dialysis payments for end-stage renal disease within the model. The agency said ADVaNCE MA is intended to put regional plans on more equal footing with large national insurers.
3. New plans would be required to demonstrate compliance with network adequacy standards during their first year of operation rather than during the application process. CMS said the change would remove a barrier to market entry and reduce application appeals and bid delays.
4. Medicare Advantage food and beverage supplemental benefits would have to consist of whole, nutrient-dense foods that align with the 2025-2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans. This includes the food and produce benefit for chronically ill enrollees, which was used nearly 40 million times in 2025. Items that do not meet the standard, such as certain high-calorie oral nutritional supplements, could still be covered if a provider recommends them based on an enrollee’s medical needs.
5. Clinical psychology, clinical social work and outpatient behavioral health would be combined into one specialty category for network adequacy purposes. CMS also proposed expanding the telehealth credit plans can use to meet network adequacy standards.
6. The proposal would allow more plan options and competition in markets with dual-eligible special needs plans, or D-SNPs. It would also permit more flexible arrangements between D-SNPs and Medicaid managed care plans.