1 insurer holds at least half the commercial market in 47% of metro areas: AMA

Advertisement

One health insurer holds at least half the commercial market in 47% of U.S. metropolitan areas, according to a new analysis from the American Medical Association.

The study, released Nov. 17, examined 2025 data from 385 metro areas in all 50 states and the District of Columbia. It identified the two largest insurers in each market and measured market concentration using the federal merger guidelines issued in December 2023. Markets that exceeded the guidelines’ thresholds were classified as “highly concentrated.”

Here are eight things to know:

1. At least one insurer held a commercial market share of 30% or more in 90% of metro areas, and one insurer held at least 50% in 47% of metros.

2. At least one insurer held a Medicare Advantage market share of 30% or more in 88% of metro areas, and one insurer’s share was at least 50% in 25% of metros.

3. Under the federal guidelines, 95% of metro area commercial markets were highly concentrated in 2025, the same share as in 2014. In Medicare Advantage, 97% of metro markets were highly concentrated in 2025, down from 99% in 2017.

4. The 10 states with the least competitive commercial health insurance markets, in order, were Alabama, Kentucky, Hawaii, Louisiana, Michigan, Illinois, Alaska, Indiana, Vermont and West Virginia.

5. The 10 states with the least competitive Medicare Advantage markets, in order, were Wyoming, Vermont, the District of Columbia, Rhode Island, Montana, Idaho, Oklahoma, Utah, Colorado and Louisiana.

6. Commercial market concentration reached a 10-year high in six states: Connecticut, Illinois, Indiana, Montana, South Dakota and West Virginia.

7. UnitedHealth Group had the largest national commercial market share at 15%, followed by CVS Health’s Aetna (12%), Elevance Health (12%), Cigna (8%), Health Care Service Corp. (8%), Kaiser Permanente (6%), Centene (4%), Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (2%), Blue Cross Blue Shield of Florida (2%) and Blue Shield of California (2%). Taken together, Blue Cross Blue Shield insurers would top the list with a combined 42% commercial market share.

8. UnitedHealth Group also led the national Medicare Advantage market with a 30% share, followed by Humana (17%), CVS Health’s Aetna (12%), Kaiser Permanente (6%), Elevance Health (6%), Centene (3%), Cigna (2%), Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (2%), Highmark (1%) and Healthfirst (1%).

Advertisement

Next Up in Financial Management

Advertisement