Judge dismisses Tampa General’s 340B suit against Lilly

Advertisement

A federal judge dismissed Tampa (Fla.) General Hospital’s lawsuit against Eli Lilly over its 340B claims data requirement, ruling Nov. 18 that the hospital’s state-law claims cannot proceed in court and pointing to HHS’ administrative dispute process as an avenue for resolving the dispute. The dismissal is without prejudice, and the hospital has 30 days to file an amended complaint.

In the order, a federal judge granted Lilly’s request to dismiss the case after reviewing the filings and hearing arguments. The judge relied on a 2011 Supreme Court decision, Astra USA v. Santa Clara County, which found that Congress did not give 340B hospitals the right to sue drugmakers directly over 340B pricing. The order said the Supreme Court barred those claims “no matter the clothing” the hospitals dress them in because HHS, not individual hospitals, oversees 340B pricing and supply.

The judge wrote that Tampa General’s Florida consumer protection claims effectively try to enforce the 340B program’s rules, specifically to get discounted drugs without giving Lilly the data it wants on how those drugs are used. Allowing the suit would “encourage piecemeal litigation,” the order said, undermining Congress’ plan to run the program uniformly nationwide. The judge noted the hospital still has options: HHS runs its own process for resolving 340B disputes, which appears to cover these claims, and the results of that process may be reviewed by a court.

Tampa General sued Lilly July 2, alleging the drugmaker’s decision to cut off its 340B pricing after the hospital refused to submit claims-level data violated Florida’s Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act. Lilly cut off the hospital’s access June 18, and the hospital said it was paying 25% to 50% more on average for Lilly drugs. The hospital asked the court to restore its discounts, block Lilly’s reporting requirement and award damages.

The ruling comes as other hospitals challenge the policy in other courts. Lebanon, N.H.-based Dartmouth Health’s Mary Hitchcock Memorial Hospital also sued Lilly in July, and five Massachusetts hospitals sued Lilly Oct. 27 under the state’s consumer protection law.

Advertisement

Next Up in Pharmacy

Advertisement