Nearly two-thirds of health systems using Epic plan to replace at least one standalone AI application with an EHR-native tool by 2028, according to a new Black Book Research report.
The November report found that 63% of Epic-based health systems intend to make such a replacement, compared with 34% of organizations using other EHR platforms.
The findings come as health systems reevaluate their AI investments amid growing competition from EHR vendors and concerns about whether standalone applications are delivering their promised financial returns.
The study incorporated 412 verified healthcare AI buyers and findings from Black Book’s 2026 healthcare technology user-experience panel. The research was conducted from Sept. 12 to Nov. 4 and included CIOs, chief digital officers, CFOs, clinical leaders, hospital board members and other healthcare executives. Participating organizations represented Epic, Oracle Health, Meditech, Athenahealth and other technology environments.
Here are five key findings from the report:
- The median health system expects to reduce its standalone AI vendor portfolio from nine companies to five by 2028, a roughly 44% reduction. Among health systems in the highest quartile of AI vendor adoption, the anticipated decrease is even greater, from 17 vendors to eight.
- Financial performance is contributing to those decisions. Buyers reported realizing a median of just 41% of the financial returns AI vendors originally promised.
- Meanwhile, 57% of surveyed buyers identified the availability of a comparable EHR-native capability as a reason they would discontinue a standalone AI vendor. Another 49% cited failure to achieve promised returns on investment, while 36% pointed to concerns about a vendor’s potential acquisition or failure.
- Some categories of healthcare AI appear more vulnerable to replacement than others. Ambient clinical documentation received the lowest score, 56 out of 100, on Black Book’s AI vendor Survival Index, which evaluates customer renewal intentions, potential displacement by EHR-native capabilities, financial returns, perceived vendor stability and platform breadth. Buyers also expect only three of today’s 11 major ambient documentation vendors to remain independent by 2028.
- Imaging and pathology AI received the highest score at 73, followed by patient communications and AI contact center technologies at 71. Clinical decision support and search scored 66, revenue cycle AI scored 64, and AI governance and orchestration scored 60.
The index measures buyers’ assessments rather than the statistical likelihood that a particular company will survive.
The report also identified potential gaps in health systems’ AI vendor contracts. Seventy-seven percent of AI contracts lacked exit rights if an EHR vendor introduced an equivalent native capability, while 71% lacked termination rights tied to a change of control.
Additionally, 61% of hospital board respondents believed their AI contracts provided protection in the event of a vendor acquisition, compared with 24% of CIOs.
Black Book said the findings reflect buyer assessments and expectations rather than confirmed vendor exits. The research was not sponsored by an AI vendor.