For Nolan Chang, MD, the most important outcome of implementing healthcare AI isn’t time saved or costs cut. It’s whether patients trust their physicians more.
Dr. Chang, executive vice president of strategy, corporate development and finance at Oakland, Calif.-based The Permanente Federation, told Becker’s that rebuilding trust is his top priority, and that the organization’s technology choices are designed to serve that goal.
Trust as strategy
Dr. Chang said trust between patients, communities and the healthcare system was shaken during the pandemic, and restoring it now shapes the rest of the organization’s strategy.
“We tend to be a relationship-based organization, and in that relationship, it’s a two-way communication street,” he said.
“How are we making sure that we’re out there communicating what we’re trying to do, re-establishing that trust, not only with the patients and communities, but also with the payers, to make sure that we’re relevant?” Dr. Chang said. “And then that feeds all the downstream strategies, because the times have changed so strongly.”
That relationship-first approach is rooted in Kaiser Permanente’s integrated model, where members often stay for years. Dr. Chang said the long-term relationship changes how physicians think about care.
“The easiest way I explain it — and this is how I explain it to our new physicians that come on board — we win when our patients win,” he said.
That alignment shows up in costs, he said. “So for us, if our patients are healthy, the costs go down.”
Dr. Chang said that long view matters because the conditions physicians treat today often started much earlier.
“By the time you develop congestive heart failure or a stroke, the intervention wasn’t two years ago,” he said. “The intervention was maybe decades ago. And so the healthier we keep people upstream, the lower the overall healthcare costs are downstream.”
‘Augmented,’ not ‘artificial’
Dr. Chang said the organization’s AI tools should be judged by how well they support that relationship, starting with how the technology is described.
“We oftentimes say it’s not artificial intelligence. Artificial sounds really scary,” he said. “I’ve always said it’s about augmented intelligence. What are we trying to augment, and how is it really staying true to our mission?”
With ambient AI documentation, physicians can focus on the patient instead of a screen, which Dr. Chang said matters most in difficult moments.
“So with the ambient AI, instead of focusing on a computer or my keyboard, it really is focusing on body language, looking the patients in the eye, making that connection to really understand them,” he said. “But also, so they know that I’m listening; they know that I care. That goes a long way in building trust.”
He added that physicians still play a key role in making sure the technology gets it right.
“By eliminating the need for the physician to type and look at a computer screen during consultations, ambient AI enables physicians to make direct eye contact and engage more fully with patients, which builds trust,” Dr. Chang said. “Of course, physicians need to review and edit the notes for accuracy before adding it to the patient record. Patients have also reported that the ambient AI scribe had a positive impact on the quality of their visit.”
He said that connection is especially important when a patient receives unexpected news.
“Say I give you a diagnosis that you weren’t planning on or really don’t want,” Dr. Chang said. “That’s a lot of discretionary energy that you have to focus on just receiving that message, much less trying to figure out what you have to do to get that under control.”
Virtual tools follow the same principle. Dr. Chang compared them to the ways people kept in touch with friends and family during the pandemic, through texting, video and social media, and said the organization uses digital tools to learn patients’ preferences and communicate in their language.
“We have all these tools in healthcare right now, these virtual tools, but they’re all tools to maintain a relationship,” he said.
Redefining access
Dr. Chang said the organization’s messaging tools also reflect a broader view of what access should mean.
“Access isn’t about when you’re able to get an appointment,” he said. “It really should be about the resolution of a concern or an issue a patient has.”
Looking ahead, Dr. Chang said value-based care gives physicians the flexibility to meet patients wherever is most convenient for them, whether in a clinic, virtually or in the community. He compared the approach to coaching: understanding a patient’s goals, then using the right tools to help them get there.
“What’s most convenient for you? Let’s meet those interactions,” he said, “because they do matter longitudinally over time.”