Landmark criminal case challenges telemedicine abortion shield laws 

A Louisiana grand jury has indicted a New York state physician for providing and mailing abortion medication to a Louisiana resident via telehealth in what appears to be the first known criminal case of its kind. 

The indictment, filed Jan. 31, directly challenges shield laws — enacted by eight states, including New York — that aim to protect clinicians from prosecution when prescribing abortion medications to patients in states with bans.The case could test the limits of those protections, legal experts suggest, and have implications for health systems that operate telehealth services across state lines.

Court records indicate Margaret Carpenter, MD, prescribed the medication in April 2024 for a minor in Louisiana under New York's telemedicine abortion shield law. She has been charged with criminal abortion by means of abortion-inducing drugs and a warrant was issued for her arrest. If convicted, the felony charge carries a one- to five-year sentence, according to The Advocate. 

Tony Clayton, district attorney for the 18th Judicial District, which includes West Baton Rouge Parish, said the charges reflect Louisiana's position that abortion is illegal within its borders, regardless of where the provider is located. State Attorney General Liz Murrill also framed the case as one involving coercion, alleging that the minor did not consent to the abortion and that the pills were provided at the direction of her mother, who was also charged.

Legal experts anticipate that this case will move through the federal courts and could ultimately reach the U.S. Supreme Court, raising questions about state jurisdiction and the enforceability of shield laws, according to The New York Times. The outcome could shape the legal landscape for telemedicine providers and influence how health systems navigate compliance with both state and federal regulations. The case also highlights potential risks for clinicians practicing under shield laws and may lead to increased scrutiny of cross-state telehealth services.

This indictment also follows a separate legal challenge against Dr. Carpenter in Texas, where she faces a civil lawsuit for prescribing abortion medication to a Texas resident. 

Copyright © 2025 Becker's Healthcare. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy. Cookie Policy. Linking and Reprinting Policy.

 

Articles We Think You'll Like

 

Featured Whitepapers

Featured Webinars